Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
April 30, 1830
Phenix Gazette
Alexandria, Virginia
What is this article about?
This editorial criticizes the Telegraph, a government-aligned newspaper, for publishing contradictory articles about political attacks on Thomas Jefferson's birthday celebration held on the 13th instant in the city. It highlights inconsistencies in reporting on the event's coverage by other presses and letter writers.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
It is a long time since we have referred to the opinions of the Telegraph, because, although styled the "official Government Journal," it clearly has not the confidence of those whom it endeavors to support. We now cite from its veritable columns, an amusing specimen of contradiction in language and sentiments, showing that the compilators of its editorial articles do not themselves know exactly how to chime in with each other.
In the Telegraph of Wednesday we have the following:
It is in this point of view, it is as attacking Mr. Jefferson's memory—that we are to consider the attacks now making on the anniversary celebration of his birth day, which took place in this city on the 13th instant. Since that day a systematic warfare has been carried on, by a certain political party, on the event itself, and all the persons and incidents connected with it.—From North, South, East and West, a concentric fire is poured in.
For the '..letter writers from Washington.' this celebration has been a fruitful theme for misrepresentation, and the old federal prints and their young progeny have greedily received and propagated them.
In an article immediately succeeding the one from which the above extract is taken, we have the following, upon quite a different tack—the Telegraph still speaking of the celebration:
Many prints of neighboring cities, have assumed, not merely a mysterious silence, but have scarcely mentioned the festival! Even the idle, babbling, frivolous letter writers, have been dumb, or have held back their bright lucubrations or have had them suppressed. Now, why this mighty effort to rival the mysteries of Udolpho? Why all this trickery, mummery and charlatanry?
We would advise Duff to supervise the editorial articles which his kind friends furnish him with, or at least, to adopt some plan for not telling two different tales, in one, and the same paper, about the same thing. Our readers will readily see the contradictions, into which these paragraph grinders have run.
In the Telegraph of Wednesday we have the following:
It is in this point of view, it is as attacking Mr. Jefferson's memory—that we are to consider the attacks now making on the anniversary celebration of his birth day, which took place in this city on the 13th instant. Since that day a systematic warfare has been carried on, by a certain political party, on the event itself, and all the persons and incidents connected with it.—From North, South, East and West, a concentric fire is poured in.
For the '..letter writers from Washington.' this celebration has been a fruitful theme for misrepresentation, and the old federal prints and their young progeny have greedily received and propagated them.
In an article immediately succeeding the one from which the above extract is taken, we have the following, upon quite a different tack—the Telegraph still speaking of the celebration:
Many prints of neighboring cities, have assumed, not merely a mysterious silence, but have scarcely mentioned the festival! Even the idle, babbling, frivolous letter writers, have been dumb, or have held back their bright lucubrations or have had them suppressed. Now, why this mighty effort to rival the mysteries of Udolpho? Why all this trickery, mummery and charlatanry?
We would advise Duff to supervise the editorial articles which his kind friends furnish him with, or at least, to adopt some plan for not telling two different tales, in one, and the same paper, about the same thing. Our readers will readily see the contradictions, into which these paragraph grinders have run.
What sub-type of article is it?
Partisan Politics
Press Freedom
What keywords are associated?
Telegraph Contradictions
Jefferson Birthday
Political Attacks
Press Inconsistencies
Government Journal
What entities or persons were involved?
Telegraph
Mr. Jefferson
Duff
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Contradictions In Telegraph's Coverage Of Jefferson's Birthday Celebration
Stance / Tone
Mocking And Critical Of The Telegraph's Inconsistencies
Key Figures
Telegraph
Mr. Jefferson
Duff
Key Arguments
Telegraph Claims Systematic Attacks On Jefferson's Birthday Celebration From All Directions
Telegraph Contradicts Itself By Noting Silence And Suppression In Other Presses About The Event
Editorial Writers In Telegraph Lack Coordination And Confidence