Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
October 13, 1807
The New Hampshire Gazette
Portsmouth, Rockingham County, New Hampshire
What is this article about?
The editorial criticizes Federalist newspapers for circulating a caricature of Georgia militia as awkward and effeminate, portraying it as traitorous propaganda to undermine U.S. readiness for war with Britain. It defends the militia and accuses Federalists of inviting foreign insults.
OCR Quality
100%
Excellent
Full Text
Federal papers have given a ready circulation to a ludicrous description of a company of Georgia militia.
Though it may reasonably be supposed, from some instances of imperfection, visible even in the militia of New-England, that a very awkward company might be found in the back settlement of Georgia ; yet none that could equal this federal picture. The description is carried too far for ordinary credulity to follow. It is a wanton caricature.
It is not unworthy of remark, that this disparaging representation finds the earliest reception in the papers which have been the first to represent our incompetency to maintain any claim against the arms of Great Britain. They have told us that this country will be ruined by England, if we go to war with her--and to support this, they exhibit a caricature of the awkwardness and effeminacy of both officers and soldiers of our militia!
Yes-the same villainous traitors who by their language have invited the insults of foreign powers, by declaring our rulers to be weak pusillanimous wretches, and our citizens so distracted by party spirit as to be unable to unite in common defence, would now persuade the world that our militia is composed of a rabble not only rude but effeminate!
It is a libel-it is a calumny.
But suppose it was true. Is this a time when it should be wantonly and unnecessarily proclaimed to the world?
If a soldier, belonging to a garrison that is menaced by an enemy, communicates to that enemy a description of the vulnerable points of the fortress, is he less a traitor because that description is true?
Boston Democrat.
Though it may reasonably be supposed, from some instances of imperfection, visible even in the militia of New-England, that a very awkward company might be found in the back settlement of Georgia ; yet none that could equal this federal picture. The description is carried too far for ordinary credulity to follow. It is a wanton caricature.
It is not unworthy of remark, that this disparaging representation finds the earliest reception in the papers which have been the first to represent our incompetency to maintain any claim against the arms of Great Britain. They have told us that this country will be ruined by England, if we go to war with her--and to support this, they exhibit a caricature of the awkwardness and effeminacy of both officers and soldiers of our militia!
Yes-the same villainous traitors who by their language have invited the insults of foreign powers, by declaring our rulers to be weak pusillanimous wretches, and our citizens so distracted by party spirit as to be unable to unite in common defence, would now persuade the world that our militia is composed of a rabble not only rude but effeminate!
It is a libel-it is a calumny.
But suppose it was true. Is this a time when it should be wantonly and unnecessarily proclaimed to the world?
If a soldier, belonging to a garrison that is menaced by an enemy, communicates to that enemy a description of the vulnerable points of the fortress, is he less a traitor because that description is true?
Boston Democrat.
What sub-type of article is it?
Partisan Politics
Military Affairs
War Or Peace
What keywords are associated?
Federalist Caricature
Georgia Militia
Anti War Propaganda
Military Defense
Partisan Libel
British Threat
What entities or persons were involved?
Federal Papers
Georgia Militia
New England Militia
Great Britain
Boston Democrat
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Defense Of Georgia Militia Against Federalist Caricature
Stance / Tone
Strongly Accusatory Towards Federalists As Traitors
Key Figures
Federal Papers
Georgia Militia
New England Militia
Great Britain
Boston Democrat
Key Arguments
Federal Description Of Georgia Militia Is A Ludicrous Caricature
Federal Papers Promote Anti War Sentiments By Disparaging U.S. Military
Such Representations Invite Foreign Insults And Aid Enemies
Disparaging Militia Is Libelous And Traitorous, Even If True