Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Martinsburg Gazette And Public Advertiser
Story May 3, 1827

Martinsburg Gazette And Public Advertiser

Martinsburg, Berkeley County, West Virginia

What is this article about?

An anecdote from about 20 years ago describes Thomas Paine arguing against the Bible with friends at his boarding house. An intruder counters by praising Bible-devout Scots for their happiness and reliability, silencing Paine who then leaves upstairs.

Clipping

OCR Quality

92% Excellent

Full Text

An anecdote of Thomas Paine

-One very warm evening, about twenty years ago, passing the house where Thomas boarded, the lower window was open, and seeing him sitting close by, and being on speaking terms, I stepped in for a half hour's chat; seven or eight of his friends were also present, whose doubts and his own he was laboring to remove by a long talk about the story of Joshua commanding the sun and moon to stand still, &c., and concluded by denouncing the Bible as the worst of books, and that it had occasioned more mischief and bloodshed than any book ever printed--and was believed only by fools and designing knaves, &c.

Here he paused, and while he was replenishing the tumbler with his favorite brandy and water, a person, who I afterwards found was an intruder, like myself, asked Mr Paine if he ever was in Scotland?

'The answer was, yes So have I been, continues the speaker; and the Scotch are the greatest bigots with the Bible I ever met--it is their schoolbook. Their houses and churches are furnished with Bibles, and if they travel but a few miles from home, their Bible is always their companion: yet, continues the speaker, in no country where I have travelled have I seen the people so comfortable and happy; their poor are not in such abject poverty as I have seen in other countries: by their bigoted custom of going to church on Sundays, they save the wages which they earn through the week, which in other countries that I have visited, is generally spent by mechanics and other young men in taverns and frolic on Sundays; and of all the foreigners who land on our shores, none are so much sought after for servants, and to fill places where trust is reposed, as the Scotch: you rarely find them in taverns, the watch house, bridewell, or state prison.

Now, says he, if the Bible is so bad a book, those who use it most would be the worst of people, but the reverse is the case This was a sort of argument Paine was not prepared to answer, and a historical fact which could not be denied--so without saying a word, he lifted a candle from the table, and walked up stairs; his disciples slipped out one by one, and left the speaker and T. to enjoy the scene.--N Y Spectator

What sub-type of article is it?

Biography Curiosity

What themes does it cover?

Moral Virtue Social Manners

What keywords are associated?

Thomas Paine Bible Debate Scotland Anecdote Religious Argument

What entities or persons were involved?

Thomas Paine The Speaker T.

Where did it happen?

The House Where Thomas Boarded

Story Details

Key Persons

Thomas Paine The Speaker T.

Location

The House Where Thomas Boarded

Event Date

About Twenty Years Ago

Story Details

Narrator visits Thomas Paine during a Bible-denouncing talk with friends. Intruder praises Bible-loving Scots for their happiness, thrift, and reliability, silencing Paine who leaves without reply.

Are you sure?