Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
July 14, 1802
The Recorder, Or, Lady's And Gentleman's Miscellany
Richmond, Virginia
What is this article about?
Editorial denouncing Maryland Congressman Dennis' impertinent and untrue speech criticizing Virginia Congressman Giles during Judiciary bill debates, quoting Dennis' sarcastic comparison of Giles to an ignis fatuus and reference to Callender's biased history.
OCR Quality
95%
Excellent
Full Text
In the debates on the Judiciary bill, Mr. Giles received a small rub from one Dennis, a member of Congress from Maryland. The speech of the latter is full of impertinence and untruth. But here follows the passage to which we refer.
"Such a genius is the gentleman from Virginia (Mr. Giles.) That gentleman we all know has light in abundance, and if the path we have to explore be dark and intricate, he might have taken his lanthorn and have gone before us: we should have been glad to have followed him, and had the benefit of his illumination. But he has departed from the highway leading to the place of destination, and like an ignis fatuus; has attempted to lead us through bogs and morasses, in order that we might be mired, or get lost, on the way;
The gentleman commenced his observations by giving us a retrospective narrative of the rise and progress of political parties, their respective views, and their different tendencies. And truly, sir, the history which he gave us was such a one as I have long since read in Callender's history of the United States, and his Prospect Before Us; but such a one as I had not expected from the Gentleman of Virginia."
"Such a genius is the gentleman from Virginia (Mr. Giles.) That gentleman we all know has light in abundance, and if the path we have to explore be dark and intricate, he might have taken his lanthorn and have gone before us: we should have been glad to have followed him, and had the benefit of his illumination. But he has departed from the highway leading to the place of destination, and like an ignis fatuus; has attempted to lead us through bogs and morasses, in order that we might be mired, or get lost, on the way;
The gentleman commenced his observations by giving us a retrospective narrative of the rise and progress of political parties, their respective views, and their different tendencies. And truly, sir, the history which he gave us was such a one as I have long since read in Callender's history of the United States, and his Prospect Before Us; but such a one as I had not expected from the Gentleman of Virginia."
What sub-type of article is it?
Partisan Politics
Legal Reform
What keywords are associated?
Judiciary Bill
Congressional Debate
Political Parties
Ignis Fatuus
Callender's History
What entities or persons were involved?
Mr. Giles (Virginia)
Dennis (Maryland)
Congress
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Criticism Of Dennis' Attack On Giles In Judiciary Bill Debate
Stance / Tone
Defensive Of Giles, Condemnatory Of Dennis' Impertinence
Key Figures
Mr. Giles (Virginia)
Dennis (Maryland)
Congress
Key Arguments
Dennis' Speech Is Full Of Impertinence And Untruth
Dennis Sarcastically Compares Giles To An Ignis Fatuus Leading Astray
Dennis Accuses Giles Of Relying On Callender's Biased Political History