Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Prison Mirror
Editorial March 9, 1950

The Prison Mirror

Stillwater, Washington County, Minnesota

What is this article about?

Convicts at Stillwater prison respond indignantly to a St. Paul Dispatch reader's suggestion to use inmates for medical experiments instead of dogs, defending their humanity and right to humane treatment amid calls for brotherhood and reform.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

In the February 24th issue of the St. Paul Dispatch, we read an item in the "Open Forum for Readers," from the pen of Mrs. Alraine Smith, as follows:

"Sir: I have been reading in the papers about the dogs in the pound to be used in experiments. I think it is cruel to take a poor helpless dog to practice on it. Why not go to Stillwater and take some of those charges and experiment on them. That would be doing something good for our race."

In this enlightened age, and during the so-called "Brotherhood" week; when the blood thirsty cruelties practiced against convicts have largely been relegated to the dark ages; for anyone, supposedly in their right mind, to go into public print and place inmates of this institution in a category lower than the dog, and less entitled to humane treatment, is beyond our comprehension.

We are convicts, yes; have made our mistakes, and are paying society for those mistakes, but we were created by the same Supreme Being, from the same material as the writer, and have the same medium of thought, hopes and despairs; yes, and in most cases, a more acute sense of justice than the writer quoted above, exhibits.

What sub-type of article is it?

Crime Or Punishment Social Reform

What keywords are associated?

Convict Rights Humane Treatment Prison Reform Animal Experiments Brotherhood Week

What entities or persons were involved?

Mrs. Alraine Smith St. Paul Dispatch Stillwater Convicts

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Defense Of Humane Treatment For Convicts

Stance / Tone

Indignant Defense Of Prisoner Humanity

Key Figures

Mrs. Alraine Smith St. Paul Dispatch Stillwater Convicts

Key Arguments

Suggestion To Experiment On Convicts Instead Of Dogs Is Cruel And Dehumanizing Convicts Deserve Humane Treatment Like Animals Convicts Are Created By The Same Supreme Being As Others And Share Human Thoughts And Justice

Are you sure?