Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Davenport Gazette
Filler October 12, 1848

The Davenport Gazette

Davenport, Scott County, Iowa

What is this article about?

Anecdote of Judge Parsons, a lawyer who argued opposite sides of two identical cases on the same day, using different arguments each time. When questioned by the judge, he wittily replied that he might have been wrong earlier but now knew he was right, and won both verdicts.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

Anecdote of Judge Parsons.--When Judge Parsons was a practising lawyer, he was once employed to plead two cases in court, which were precisely alike, but in one he was engaged for the defendant, in the other for the plaintiff. It happened that both cases were tried the same day. He spoke half an hour to the first jury, and the case was given to them and they had retired.--When he appeared before the second jury he made use of very different arguments from those before employed by him, of which the court took notice, reminded him that he seemed to have changed his tone, and repeating to him what he had said but a few minutes before. Mr. Parsons, fixing his keen eye upon the judge replied--"May it please your honor, I might have been wrong a half hour ago, but now I know I am right." He proceeded; and when the juries returned it was found that he had gained the verdict in both cases.

What sub-type of article is it?

Human Interest Witty Remark

What keywords are associated?

Judge Parsons Lawyer Anecdote Court Cases Witty Reply Legal Argument

What entities or persons were involved?

Judge Parsons

Filler Details

Topic

Clever Lawyer Winning Both Sides Of Identical Cases With Witty Reply

Key Persons

Judge Parsons

Event Details

Judge Parsons argued for opposite sides in two identical court cases on the same day, using different arguments. When the judge noted the change, Parsons replied he might have been wrong earlier but now knew he was right, and won both verdicts.

Are you sure?