Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
March 15, 1838
Kentucky Gazette
Lexington, Fayette County, Kentucky
What is this article about?
Editorial condemns the duel near Washington that killed Mr. Cilley as murder, criticizes Col. Webb's support, calls for an honest congressional investigation, and defends the 'Spy in Washington' against attacks by Congress members Duncan, Bynum, and Boon.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
We have looked to the press, through our exchange papers, for the general opinion relative to the late duel in the vicinity of Washington, but find our editorial brother, Col. Webb, sustained by very few. Almost universally, the taking the life of Mr. Cilley, is pronounced MURDER.
We hope and trust, that the committee raised in Congress to investigate this matter, will discharge the duty honestly and faithfully, and whatever may be the opinion of individuals, formed by partial relations of the circumstances, and we are free to admit, that such relations have had their influence upon us, we recommend that no farther expression of opinion may be elicited until the report of that committee shall be made public.
For the blustering of our editorial brother, Col. Webb, the whole American people must have the most sovereign contempt; and as the following which we copy from the Baltimore Republican, cannot effect the deliberate opinion of any, in relation to the shedding the blood of Mr. Cilley, we give it a place in our paper.
The editor of the New York Courier & Enquirer thus notices the attack made by Dr. Duncan, Mr. Bynum, Mr. Boon, and others, upon the character of the "Spy in Washington," the correspondent of that paper.
"Mr. Wise said very justly of Mr. Gholson that if ignorance and impudence could constitute a blackguard, Mr. G. was one, and he might have included with safety Mr. Duncan in his remark; for surely, if vulgarity and ignorance, combined with a reputation for scoundrelism, which is proverbial, constitute Mr. D. a fit associate for Mr. Gholson, they may with safety be classed together.
To name the "Spy in Washington" in the same breath with Duncan, Bynum and Boon, would be to insult our intelligent correspondent to an extent which would leave us but little hope of our obtaining his forgiveness; and yet these men, feeling that they were safe in their persons by reason of their privilege as members of the House of Representatives, exhausted the whole force of their billingsgate upon an aged and respectable gentleman who is immeasurably their superior in birth, manners and education; and who, they well know, would hold them to a strict personal accountability if they had either the courage or the magnanimity to waive the protection which their being members of the house secures to them."
We copy the above from the Louisville Journal, to shew the consistency of Col. Webb. He acknowledges that Duncan, Bynum and Boon were protected by their privileges but says not a word about Cilley. To shew what amount of respectability his correspondent, the Spy, (M. L. Davis, the writer of the Jack Downing letters) is entitled to, we extract from the Ohio Eagle an article headed "Burr and Jefferson," which will be found in the preceding page.
We hope and trust, that the committee raised in Congress to investigate this matter, will discharge the duty honestly and faithfully, and whatever may be the opinion of individuals, formed by partial relations of the circumstances, and we are free to admit, that such relations have had their influence upon us, we recommend that no farther expression of opinion may be elicited until the report of that committee shall be made public.
For the blustering of our editorial brother, Col. Webb, the whole American people must have the most sovereign contempt; and as the following which we copy from the Baltimore Republican, cannot effect the deliberate opinion of any, in relation to the shedding the blood of Mr. Cilley, we give it a place in our paper.
The editor of the New York Courier & Enquirer thus notices the attack made by Dr. Duncan, Mr. Bynum, Mr. Boon, and others, upon the character of the "Spy in Washington," the correspondent of that paper.
"Mr. Wise said very justly of Mr. Gholson that if ignorance and impudence could constitute a blackguard, Mr. G. was one, and he might have included with safety Mr. Duncan in his remark; for surely, if vulgarity and ignorance, combined with a reputation for scoundrelism, which is proverbial, constitute Mr. D. a fit associate for Mr. Gholson, they may with safety be classed together.
To name the "Spy in Washington" in the same breath with Duncan, Bynum and Boon, would be to insult our intelligent correspondent to an extent which would leave us but little hope of our obtaining his forgiveness; and yet these men, feeling that they were safe in their persons by reason of their privilege as members of the House of Representatives, exhausted the whole force of their billingsgate upon an aged and respectable gentleman who is immeasurably their superior in birth, manners and education; and who, they well know, would hold them to a strict personal accountability if they had either the courage or the magnanimity to waive the protection which their being members of the house secures to them."
We copy the above from the Louisville Journal, to shew the consistency of Col. Webb. He acknowledges that Duncan, Bynum and Boon were protected by their privileges but says not a word about Cilley. To shew what amount of respectability his correspondent, the Spy, (M. L. Davis, the writer of the Jack Downing letters) is entitled to, we extract from the Ohio Eagle an article headed "Burr and Jefferson," which will be found in the preceding page.
What sub-type of article is it?
Crime Or Punishment
Partisan Politics
Press Freedom
What keywords are associated?
Duel
Cilley Murder
Col. Webb
Congressional Investigation
Spy Washington
Duncan Bynum Boon
Press Attacks
What entities or persons were involved?
Col. Webb
Mr. Cilley
Dr. Duncan
Mr. Bynum
Mr. Boon
Spy In Washington
M. L. Davis
Mr. Wise
Mr. Gholson
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Condemnation Of The Duel Killing Mr. Cilley
Stance / Tone
Strongly Critical Of The Duel And Col. Webb, Supportive Of Congressional Investigation And Press Correspondent
Key Figures
Col. Webb
Mr. Cilley
Dr. Duncan
Mr. Bynum
Mr. Boon
Spy In Washington
M. L. Davis
Mr. Wise
Mr. Gholson
Key Arguments
The Duel That Took Mr. Cilley's Life Is Pronounced Murder Almost Universally
Col. Webb's Support For The Duel Is Sustained By Few And Deserves Sovereign Contempt
Congressional Committee Should Investigate Honestly Without Premature Opinions
Attacks On The 'Spy In Washington' By Duncan, Bynum, And Boon Are Vulgar And Protected By Privilege
The Spy Is Superior In Birth, Manners, And Education To His Attackers
Webb Inconsistent In Acknowledging Privileges For Attackers But Not For Cilley