Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Nome Nugget
Editorial November 17, 1947

The Nome Nugget

Nome, Nome County, Alaska

What is this article about?

Editorial by Bruce Gustin critiques FDR's 1940 election promise that 'your boys are not going to be sent into foreign wars,' supports HUAC's contempt citation against screenwriter John Howard Lawson for refusing to answer about Communist ties, argues Congress can compel testimony on non-criminal Communism, and exposes Communists' allegiance to Moscow, including WWII stance shifts and opposition to the Marshall Plan.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

THATS THAT
By BRUCE GUSTIN

Former Assistant Secretary of War Louis A. Johnson told a Senate committee that as early as 1938 he and the late President Roosevelt knew "war was coming and we could not stay out of it."

But that isn't what Mr. Roosevelt told the American people.

A lot of fathers and mothers never will forget his Boston speech on the eve of the 1940 election when he assured them "your boys are not going to be sent into foreign wars."

Some good should come out of the House un-American activities committee's investigation of Communist activities in the moving picture industry. When John Howard Lawson, screen writer, was asked whether he is or ever has been a Communist, he refused to answer. The sub-committee conducting the probe voted a contempt citation against him. That set the stage for a judicial determination of a vital question. Does a Congressional committee have constitutional authority to ask and compel American citizens to tell whether they did or ever have been Communists?

At first thought, it might seem to be an invasion of civil rights to hale Americans before a Congressional committee and insist that they tell whether they are or ever have been Communists. Poisonous to Americanism as Communism is, it is not yet classed as a crime in this country.

The Communist party still is allowed a place on the ballot. Whether Congress can constitutionally outlaw Communism in the United States is yet to be determined.

Any American, when asked about participation in any crime, has a constitutional right to refuse to answer on the grounds that he might incriminate himself.

But that right does not apply in an inquiry into Communist activities because there is no law against being a Communist. The Congressional theory is that the investigating powers of Congress are so broad a Congressional committee can ask and require an answer to any question which does not connect a witness with a crime, no matter if his answer exposes him to public hatred and scorn.

Why any American citizen who is not and never has been a Communist should hesitate to so testify is puzzling. Being free of any Communist taint is something to be proud of, not ashamed of. Violent overthrow of our constitutional system of government is one of the aims of Communists. They should be exposed so the American people can know who their enemies are.

Communist party policy everywhere is made in Moscow. Any doubt, which may have existed, that Reds in all other countries are considered a part of the Russian Communist organization was removed recently. At a conference in Poland, Communists from nine European countries announced creation of a new Communist International "Information Bureau."

Then General Zhdanov, one of the ringleaders at this conference and member of the Russian politburo, called upon Communists and their sympathizers everywhere to join the Soviet government in a fight to wreck the Marshall plan for European rehabilitation.

Zhdanov's "appeal" to Communists everywhere to support the Russian fight against the Marshall plan was in reality an order. Publication of his statement in the Communist newspaper Pravda made it official. Russian papers operate under Soviet dictatorship. When Pravda speaks it says what the Russian government decrees it shall say. And the same men who constitute the Soviet government rule the Communist International.

That the first allegiance of Communists in the United States is to Soviet Russia, instead of to their own country, was made plain early in World War II. When the conflict started, they denounced it as an "imperialist" war and bitterly opposed American aid to Britain, France and Poland. Russia then was an ally of Germany. But when Hitler broke with Stalin and the Nazis invaded Russia, then American Communists changed their tune and acclaimed the Allied cause a "holy crusade" against Fascism.

What sub-type of article is it?

Constitutional Foreign Affairs Partisan Politics

What keywords are associated?

Communism Congressional Investigation Roosevelt Promise Marshall Plan Soviet Loyalty World War Ii Hollywood Communists

What entities or persons were involved?

Louis A. Johnson Franklin D. Roosevelt John Howard Lawson Andrei Zhdanov House Un American Activities Committee Communist Party Soviet Union

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Congressional Authority To Investigate Communists And Their Soviet Allegiance

Stance / Tone

Strongly Anti Communist And Supportive Of Investigations

Key Figures

Louis A. Johnson Franklin D. Roosevelt John Howard Lawson Andrei Zhdanov House Un American Activities Committee Communist Party Soviet Union

Key Arguments

Roosevelt Assured In 1940 That American Boys Would Not Be Sent To Foreign Wars Despite Knowing War Was Coming. Huac's Contempt Citation Against Lawson Raises Constitutional Question Of Compelling Testimony On Communist Affiliation. Communism Is Not A Crime, But Congress Can Investigate Non Criminal Activities Without Violating Self Incrimination Rights. Non Communists Should Proudly Testify To Being Free Of Communist Taint To Expose Enemies Aiming To Overthrow The Government. Communists Worldwide Follow Moscow's Policy, As Shown By The New Cominform And Zhdanov's Order To Sabotage The Marshall Plan. U.S. Communists Shifted From Opposing Wwii As 'Imperialist' To Supporting It As A 'Holy Crusade' After Nazi Invasion Of Russia.

Are you sure?