Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Sacramento Daily Record Union
Editorial September 8, 1889

Sacramento Daily Record Union

Sacramento, Sacramento County, California

What is this article about?

The editorial criticizes the Richmond Dispatch's view that Lincoln's war on the South was a blunder and that letting the seceded states alone would have restored the Union. It argues that such a policy would admit the Union's dissolubility, violate Lincoln's oath, and ignores the momentum toward a permanent Confederacy.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

It is a late day indeed to find such expression as this in a newspaper of the times. The Richmond (Va.) Dispatch says:

There never was a greater blunder committed than Mr. Lincoln committed under the advice of bad counselors when he began war upon the South. If he had allowed free institutions to have a trial—if he had let the Southern States alone—the Union feeling was so strong in all of them that public opinion would in a few years have compelled the few seceded "erring sisters" to return to their allegiance to the Union.

The Dispatch fails to see, or will not see, that the "let alone" policy would have been an admission of the dissolubility of the Union; a confession that it is but a rope of sand; a concession to the claimants holding that it was but the result of a temporary compact, severable at the will of either party. Had Mr. Lincoln consented to insurrection and the seizure of Federal property and its conversion to the purposes of the revolutionists, he would have stood before the world condemned as perjured under his oath of office. He was bound to enforce the laws, and had no power to suspend them and permit rebelling States to seize upon the national goods and convert them. We have but the "idea" of the Dispatch that the erring sisters would have seen the error of their ways and have sued for leave to return. The evidences were, and still are, that had the Confederacy been once established, it would have remained a separate and we doubt not an antagonistic power. Such talk as our contemporary indulges in at this late day is simply an exhibition of ignorance of the forces that impel men and give momentum to States.

What sub-type of article is it?

War Or Peace Constitutional Partisan Politics

What keywords are associated?

Civil War Lincoln Secession Union Preservation Confederacy Oath Of Office

What entities or persons were involved?

Mr. Lincoln Richmond (Va.) Dispatch Southern States Confederacy

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Defense Of Lincoln's War Against Southern Secession

Stance / Tone

Strongly Pro Union And Critical Of Pro Secession Views

Key Figures

Mr. Lincoln Richmond (Va.) Dispatch Southern States Confederacy

Key Arguments

Letting The South Alone Would Admit The Union's Dissolubility Lincoln Was Bound By Oath To Enforce Laws And Prevent Seizure Of Federal Property The Confederacy Would Have Become A Permanent Antagonistic Power The Dispatch's View Shows Ignorance Of Historical Forces

Are you sure?