Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Winchester Appeal
Editorial May 24, 1856

The Winchester Appeal

Winchester, Franklin County, Tennessee

What is this article about?

Editorial defends Whig vice-presidential candidate Andrew Jackson Donelson against Southern Democratic newspapers' witty mockery of his name, countering with satirical comparisons diminishing Democratic leaders like Stephens, Pierce, and Davis by likening them unfavorably to historical greats sharing their names.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

"Comparisons are Odious."

The Southern Sag Nicht organs are endeavoring to be very witty at the expense of the American candidate for the Vice Presidency. Major Donelson They attempt to make him a very small man by printing his name this way: ANDREW JACKSON donelson. This is 'small wit," and altogether worthy of modern Democracy. Andrew Jackson, it must be admitted knew his nephew better than any man could have known; he considered him not only worthy to bear his name, but worthy of his highest esteem and confidence, and the best depository of that priceless gift to him from Tennessee-- his sword. The words of love and admonition with which he accompanied this his heritage to Major Donelson, and the noble manner in which he has redeemed the pledge he made in accepting it. is well known to the country. It is a bad rule that will not work both ways, so let us apply this rule of large and small letters to some of the present great men of the Democratic party;--and as the wit originated in Georgia we will give the noble state precedence; ALEXANDER HAMILTON stephens! How does that look? Now while we accord to Mr. Stephens fine talents and respectable statesmanship, we presume his warmest admirers--and we are one of them--will not say that he is nearer the equal of the great Alexander Hamilton --the author of those matchless papers in "The Federalist" --than Andrew J. Donelson is of Andrew Jackson. FRANKLIN pierce bears about as much resemblance to the great philosopher and statesman, Franklin, as the characters we have used to spell his great name due to each other. Now we come to Mississippi. JEFFERSON davis! "Ye Gods and little fishes!" there's a name to startle states and rend republics. Jefferson Davis--Secretary of War as he is under this peaceful administration, and Great Mogul of Mississippi Democracy --is no more to be compared to the great author of our Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson, than Louis Napoleon to Napoleon Bonaparte. ALBERT GALLATIN bROWN! O, my!" John ANTHONY quitman! But, we think we hear some Democrat who has got enough of this, say, "quit man," for gracious sake!" and so we will. We might proceed, ad infinitum, to give examples, but our opponents originated the idea--being the small idea and small men party-- we simply designed showing them how small their great men appear, when placed in the same category they place Maj. Donelson. All the names we have used above, are those of gentlemen of respectable talents, but when a comparison is drawn between them and the great men whose names they bear, they dwindle at once into insignificance.--Exchange.

Our greatest glory consists not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall.

What sub-type of article is it?

Partisan Politics Satire

What keywords are associated?

Andrew Jackson Donelson Democratic Party Vice Presidency Political Mockery Historical Comparisons Southern Press Whig Defense

What entities or persons were involved?

Andrew Jackson Donelson Andrew Jackson Alexander Hamilton Stephens Franklin Pierce Jefferson Davis Albert Gallatin Brown John Anthony Quitman

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Defense Of Andrew Jackson Donelson Against Democratic Mockery

Stance / Tone

Pro Donelson, Anti Democratic, Satirical Counter Mockery

Key Figures

Andrew Jackson Donelson Andrew Jackson Alexander Hamilton Stephens Franklin Pierce Jefferson Davis Albert Gallatin Brown John Anthony Quitman

Key Arguments

Southern Democratic Newspapers Mock Donelson By Printing His Name Small After 'Andrew Jackson' Andrew Jackson Esteemed Donelson Highly And Gave Him His Sword Counter Mockery: Apply Same To Democrats Like 'Alexander Hamilton Stephens' To Show Inferiority To Historical Figures Stephens Not Equal To Alexander Hamilton Pierce Not Like Benjamin Franklin Davis Not Like Thomas Jefferson Brown Not Like Albert Gallatin Quitman Mocked Similarly Democrats Are Small Men Compared To Great Historical Namesakes

Are you sure?