Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Iron County Register
Editorial January 1, 1880

Iron County Register

Ironton, Iron County, Missouri

What is this article about?

The New York Sun defends Maine Gov. Garcelon and Council for rejecting Blaine's illegal returns, contrasting it with corrupt actions in Louisiana, urging Blaine to accept the outcome truthfully.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

The New York Sun--an independent paper, and one quite ready to lecture the Democrats when it thinks they deserve it--in reference to the Maine question, says:

"There is no kind of similitude between that case in Louisiana and this case in Maine. Wells and the notorious rogues associated with him threw out the Tilden votes arbitrarily, corruptly, and in the very teeth of the law which made them a Returning Board. Gov. Garcelon and his Council, on the other hand, reject Mr. Blaine's returns because they are "fatally defective," not merely irregular, but illegal, against the statute, and barred by the Constitution. What else could they do? Were they to admit returns which were not returns? Were the Constitution and laws of Maine to be set aside in order to put Mr. Blaine's friends in office? Or were the State officers bound in this, as in all other instances, to obey their oaths and do their sworn duty? They did not, like Wells and Anderson, undertake to inquire into the charges of bribery and intimidation, because, like Wells, they had no legal right to do that. Had the case been otherwise, however, and had the law directed them to deal judicially with these questions, the judgment would certainly have cut deeper and hurt worse. Mr. Blaine should be thankful that he comes off so easily; he should, at all events, compose himself sufficiently to speak the truth when he has so little to gain by perverting it."

What sub-type of article is it?

Partisan Politics

What keywords are associated?

Maine Question Election Returns Blaine Garcelon Louisiana Comparison Returning Board Constitutional Duty

What entities or persons were involved?

New York Sun Wells Gov. Garcelon Council Mr. Blaine Tilden Anderson

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Defense Of Maine Election Officials In Dispute Over Blaine's Returns

Stance / Tone

Strongly Supportive Of Garcelon And Critical Of Blaine

Key Figures

New York Sun Wells Gov. Garcelon Council Mr. Blaine Tilden Anderson

Key Arguments

No Similitude Between Louisiana And Maine Cases Wells Threw Out Tilden Votes Corruptly Garcelon Rejected Blaine's Returns As Fatally Defective And Illegal Officials Obeyed Oaths And Duty Did Not Inquire Into Bribery Like In Louisiana Due To No Legal Right Blaine Should Be Thankful And Speak Truth

Are you sure?