Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Cheyenne Daily Leader
Domestic News December 30, 1883

The Cheyenne Daily Leader

Cheyenne, Laramie County, Wyoming

What is this article about?

In Boston on December 29, General Butler wrote a letter explaining a mistake substituting Stickney for Pond in a communication declining to pardon Hathaway, admitting a lapse of memory due to mixing up prominent Republican convicts including Winslow, Pond, and Stickney.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

Butler's Blow.
Boston, December 29.—General Butler has written a letter to explain the substitution of the name Stickney for Pond in a recent communication to the council, declining to pardon Hathaway. The governor says the reason the mistake did not strike his attention was that he never considered that Stickney was pardoned at all. He remitted to him thirty days only, which he thought he had earned by good conduct. The governor adds:
"I admit the mistake. It was a lapse of memory. I have only one palliation to offer for it: There have been so many republican senators who were treasurers of mills, and otherwise prominent convicts in the state prison, or who would have been there if caught, that I get them a little mixed sometimes when I think about them. I cannot always distinguish the special incidents of the crime of Winslow, the Herald's friend and controlling proprietor of the Post from that of Pond, the friend of the Worcester Spy, or Stickney who was convicted, from the treasurer who ran away to Canada, who was not. Nor does it aid me any when I attempt to distinguish one as a Sabbath school teacher from the other as a preacher, as I do not always know which is which, but know one was one and the other was the other. If you will inform the public of the difficulties under which I labor when I am dealing with convicts of this high grade, for whom pardons are very much sought for by very respectable men, you will at least give them an opportunity to sympathize with me."

What sub-type of article is it?

Politics Legal Or Court Crime

What keywords are associated?

Butler Letter Pardon Mistake Republican Convicts Stickney Pond Hathaway Pardon

What entities or persons were involved?

General Butler Stickney Pond Hathaway Winslow

Where did it happen?

Boston

Domestic News Details

Primary Location

Boston

Event Date

December 29

Key Persons

General Butler Stickney Pond Hathaway Winslow

Outcome

admission of mistake in name substitution for pardon declination due to lapse of memory in distinguishing convicts.

Event Details

General Butler explained in a letter the substitution of Stickney for Pond in a communication declining to pardon Hathaway, stating he only remitted 30 days to Stickney for good conduct and never considered him fully pardoned. He attributed the error to mixing up prominent Republican convicts like Winslow, Pond, Stickney, and a treasurer who fled to Canada, noting difficulties in distinguishing their crimes, roles as Sabbath school teacher or preacher.

Are you sure?