Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Idaho World
Editorial June 19, 1873

The Idaho World

Idaho City, Boise County, Idaho

What is this article about?

The editorial mocks the 'Journal of Civilization' for its silence on the arrest of a Bender family member, attributing it to anti-Irish Catholic bias, as the journal would have sensationalized the crimes if the perpetrators were Irish. It describes the Bender murders as exceptionally cruel and hopes for justice.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

GOT A BENDER.—The "Journal of Civilization" publishes what purports to be a photograph of the senior male member of the atrocious Bender family. The countenance represented is as diabolical in appearance as are the deeds which have made the name of Bender a sound of horror even to ordinary murderers; yet for the reasons, most probably, that the Benders are not Irish Catholics—the "Journal of Civilization" refrains from comment, concerning the party arrested. There is nothing to be found in the history of crime in this country, which, for cold-blooded cruelty, treachery and cowardice, can be compared to the revolting and horrible series of murders committed by that family of Kansas devils; and if they had been committed by Patrick O'Shane, who is an Irishman and mayhap a Catholic, the "Journal of Civilization" would have foamed for months with obscene and slanderous caricature illustrations, and billingsgate editorial denunciations of the whole Irish race. But inasmuch as the murderers stubbornly and maliciously refuse to be Irish, at all, the guns of the Journal of Civilization are spiked. It has no word of encouragement for the officers—no word of condemnation for the arch murderer. We are glad, however, to be permitted to hope that justice will be finally meted out to one of the demoniac wretches, if not to all.

What sub-type of article is it?

Crime Or Punishment Satire

What keywords are associated?

Bender Family Murders Kansas Journal Of Civilization Irish Catholics Press Bias Crime History

What entities or persons were involved?

Bender Family Journal Of Civilization Patrick O'shane

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Bender Family Murders And Press Bias Against Irish Catholics

Stance / Tone

Satirical Criticism Of Selective Media Outrage

Key Figures

Bender Family Journal Of Civilization Patrick O'shane

Key Arguments

Bender Murders Exemplify Extreme Cruelty, Treachery, And Cowardice Journal Of Civilization Silent On Bender Arrest Due To Lack Of Irish Catholic Perpetrators Journal Would Have Vilified Entire Irish Race If Crimes Committed By Irishman Like Patrick O'shane Hopes For Justice Against The Bender Family

Are you sure?