Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Lewisburg Chronicle
Domestic News October 30, 1857

Lewisburg Chronicle

Lewisburg, Union County, Pennsylvania

What is this article about?

Commentary contrasting President Buchanan's assertion that the U.S. Constitution protects slavery in Kansas with Henry Clay's 1850 view that such a claim is indefensible.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

Equally Astonished.
In his New Haven reply, Pres. Buchanan thus expressed himself:
"Slavery existed at that period, and still exists, in Kansas, under the Constitution of the United States. This point has been at last settled by the highest tribunal known to our laws. How it could ever have been seriously doubted, is a mystery."

Henry Clay, who in his day was thought to have some political knowledge and mental acumen, thus expressed an astonishment which he felt on the 22d of July, 1850:
"I am aware that there are gentlemen who maintain that, in virtue of the Constitution, the right to carry slaves south of that line (36°30') already exists, and that, of course, those who maintain that opinion want no other security for the transportation of their slaves south of that line than the Constitution. If I had not heard that opinion avowed, I should have regarded it as one of the most extraordinary assumptions, and the most indefensible position that was ever taken by man."

So it will be seen that these two eminent statesmen encountered each a great mystery in the examination of the same subject. Mr. Buchanan thought it a mystery how any one could have doubted that the Constitution carries slavery with it. Mr. Clay, on the other hand, regarded that doctrine as the most extraordinary assumption he had ever heard, and the most indefensible position ever taken by man.

What sub-type of article is it?

Politics Slave Related

What keywords are associated?

Slavery Constitution Buchanan View Clay Astonishment Kansas Slavery

What entities or persons were involved?

Pres. Buchanan Henry Clay

Domestic News Details

Event Date

July 22, 1850

Key Persons

Pres. Buchanan Henry Clay

Event Details

President Buchanan expressed astonishment that anyone doubted the Constitution carries slavery into Kansas, settled by the highest tribunal. Henry Clay, on July 22, 1850, regarded the opinion that the Constitution allows carrying slaves south of the 36°30' line as an extraordinary and indefensible assumption.

Are you sure?