Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Kentucky Gazette
Editorial March 5, 1791

The Kentucky Gazette

Lexington, Fayette County, Kentucky

What is this article about?

An editorial by 'The Disinterested Citizen' urges the constitutional convention to implement separation of powers and checks between legislative, executive, and judicial branches to prevent tyranny, criticizes Virginia's government for legislative overreach, and calls for a bill of rights to secure liberties.

Merged-components note: Continuation of the editorial piece signed by 'The Disinterested Citizen' from page 2 to page 3, discussing government structure and the need for checks and balances.

Clippings

1 of 2

OCR Quality

85% Good

Full Text

As the members who are to compose the ensuing convention, are to be delegated for the truly important purpose of securing the liberty and happiness, of millions of the unborn, by the formation of a well organized system of government, they will not therefore be indifferent towards the interposition of proper barriers between, the legislative, executive and judiciary departments — as this is a principle in politics, so universally admitted since the general civilization of mankind, it would be almost needless to mention it here, were we not apprehensive of some partial bias, some hasty prejudice or prepossession, in favor of former precedents—Man

is an imitative animal, whether he acts in a private or public sphere. And both communities and individuals are found to be alike swayed by example. We therefore hope that our convention will with manly abhorrence and detestation avoid the example of the Virginian government, in this respect, at least, as one of the greatest evils— For it is notorious that, in that government the legislature may assume whatever powers it pleases—

Nay, I will not scruple to say, that there have been already in that
State, some unconstitutional assumptions of authority which without descending to the odious task of pouring them out, will serve to shew, how much reason we have, to wish an escape, from such evils, by avoiding the causes from which their infelicity is or may be derived. No government under the sun, can be safe without checks--. That thirst after power so naturally inherent in the human breast, loudly proclaims its necessity --For if any one class, of men, have it in their power to depress and usurp on the rest, it will doubtless be done, and none but their own interests in exclusion of all others will ever predominate--Therefore if the government be so arranged as to cause the several departments to be composed of different orders of men. it will naturally and consequently introduce, the strongest and safest checks and barriers: Which with the addition of a constitutional line drawn to prevent interferences, will operate as a very great preservative against all tyrannic usurpations-- The great and inestimable rights of mankind, will likely very probably be secured and established by it. It might not be improper to have them guarded in the plainest and most unequivocal manner by provision of a bill of rights. It is to what the subject produces which ever occurred or any other nation hath produced institution this subject--alluding to the conduct of the people of Virginia, his words are as follows. She has most cautiously and guardedly secured and preserved those inestimable, invaluable rights and privileges, which no people inspired with the real glow of the patriotic love of freedom, ever did or ever will abandon.

The Disinterested Citizen.

The disinterested Citizen will in a future paper, shew the necessity of a bill of rights, in our hereafter to be constructed government, by an endeavouring at refutation of the principles urged by those who were opposed to the insertion of that provision, in the federal constitution.

IV. Abstract Conclusion.

What sub-type of article is it?

Constitutional

What keywords are associated?

Separation Of Powers Checks And Balances Bill Of Rights Constitutional Convention Virginia Government Tyranny Prevention

What entities or persons were involved?

Virginian Government The Disinterested Citizen

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Separation Of Powers And Bill Of Rights In Constitutional Convention

Stance / Tone

Advocacy For Checks And Balances Against Tyranny

Key Figures

Virginian Government The Disinterested Citizen

Key Arguments

Convention Must Establish Barriers Between Legislative, Executive, And Judicial Departments Avoid Virginia's Example Where Legislature Assumes Excessive Powers No Government Safe Without Checks Due To Human Thirst For Power Separate Departments From Different Orders Of Men Provide Strongest Barriers Bill Of Rights Needed To Plainly Guard Inestimable Rights

Are you sure?