Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Southern Christian Advocate
Letter to Editor September 11, 1846

Southern Christian Advocate

Charleston, Charleston County, South Carolina

What is this article about?

A letter to the editors of the Southern Christian Advocate recounts a man's religious history where reading Stackhouse's 'History of the Bible' at age 19 shook his faith for over 40 years due to unfamiliarity with infidelity or poor objection handling. The writer asks for the editors' views on implications for educating youth about Christianity's objections.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

For the Southern Christian Advocate.
HOW IS THIS?

Messrs. Editors,-I recently met with an intelligent gentleman of much reading and reflection, in whose religious history I was much interested, as he was under deep religious concern when he related it to me. And at some of the facts I was surprised, particularly at the following:-He was brought up by strictly religious parents, but left them and went abroad into the world at about nineteen. Up to that time he was utterly unacquainted with all the forms of infidelity, and had never heard one of the objections that are brought against christianity. Under these circumstances he met with "Stackhouse's history of the Bible," which he read attentively,the reading of which, particularly the objections to Christianity which the author introduces, shook his faith in the system, to such an extent, that he had not recovered from it in more than forty years. Now as he read the whole work, the objections, and the author's answers, why did the work produce this effect upon his mind? Was it from the fact that he was wholly unacquainted with the subject up to that time, and its novelty made it more effective, or was it from the unskilful manner in which the author has disposed of these objections?

Upon the solution of the above questions I conceive considerable consequences to depend. If the result grew out of the first circumstance, then important questions arise as to the time and manner of making known to the young, the fact, and nature of objections to Christianity. If out of the latter, then manifestly, this is a dangerous book for the young and inexperienced. Will you, Messrs. Editors, look at this subject, and give us in a few words your views?

WATCHMAN.
August 29.

What sub-type of article is it?

Religious Philosophical Reflective

What themes does it cover?

Religion Education Morality

What keywords are associated?

Stackhouse Bible History Christianity Objections Religious Education Faith Shaken Infidelity Forms Youth Exposure

What entities or persons were involved?

Watchman Messrs. Editors

Letter to Editor Details

Author

Watchman

Recipient

Messrs. Editors

Main Argument

a man's faith in christianity was shaken for over 40 years by reading stackhouse's 'history of the bible,' particularly its objections, despite the author's answers; the writer questions if this resulted from the man's prior unfamiliarity with infidelity or the book's unskilled handling, and seeks editors' views on implications for exposing youth to such objections.

Notable Details

Brought Up By Strictly Religious Parents Left Home At Nineteen Unacquainted With Forms Of Infidelity Stackhouse's History Of The Bible Shook His Faith... Not Recovered In More Than Forty Years Dangerous Book For The Young And Inexperienced

Are you sure?