Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Gilpin Observer
Story March 22, 1906

Gilpin Observer

Central City, Gilpin County, Colorado

What is this article about?

Article praises Prof. Lounsbury of Yale for defending the plural use of 'none' as subject in Harper's Magazine, criticizing grammarians who enforce 'none is' over natural 'none are.'

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

"None is" or "None Are."?

All the friends of liberty of speech owe gratitude to Prof. Lounsbury of Yale for his defense in Harper's Magazine of the use of "none" as the subject of a plural verb. What idiot precisionist it was that started the movement to schoolmaster that use of "none" out of existence we do not know, but his effort has had a deplorable degree of success. An awful example ought to be made of some of the grammarians who try to make language conform to rules instead of making rules conform to language. It will take years to untwist the tongues of worthy people who have compelled themselves to say "none is" when their natural impulse was to say "none are."--Harper's Weekly.

What sub-type of article is it?

Curiosity

What themes does it cover?

Moral Virtue

What keywords are associated?

Grammar Debate None Are Language Rules Prof Lounsbury Harpers Magazine

What entities or persons were involved?

Prof. Lounsbury

Story Details

Key Persons

Prof. Lounsbury

Story Details

Prof. Lounsbury defends using 'none' with plural verb in Harper's Magazine; criticizes grammarians for enforcing rigid rules against natural language usage.

Are you sure?