Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
October 13, 1880
Sacramento Daily Record Union
Sacramento, Sacramento County, California
What is this article about?
Editorial critiques Governor Murray's view on anti-polygamy laws in Utah, arguing enforcement fails without public support, akin to Reconstruction's failure in the South; advocates depriving powers and using education to change sentiment.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
GOVERNOR MURRAY ON POLYGAMY.
Governor Murray, of Utah, represents to the General Government the uselessness of enacting laws against polygamy unless they are enforced. Governor Murray has lived in Utah, and yet he does not appear to have perceived the real nature of the difficulties with which Congress has to do. Between the conditions which obtain at the South, and those of Utah, there is no difference in essentials. In both cases it has been found impossible to enforce laws which are opposed by the public sentiment of the dominant elements of society. All history teaches that where this condition exists the imposition of obnoxious laws upon the community is impracticable without the employment of a degree of force which very few powers have ever been able to command, and the use of which in this country would be incompatible with republican principles. This is the truth, and this it is which has baffled Congress so long, and has blunted all the weapons it has tried against the Mormon institution. General Grant gave Reconstruction a full trial at the South, and when he went out of office he had to acknowledge that it was a complete failure. It was so because the Southern people were out of sympathy with the principles it was sought to enforce, and because they were out of sympathy with these principles the South is solid to-day. There is nothing to be done in such cases but to deprive the recalcitrant community of the powers of evil, and trust to example and education for a change of sentiment. This applies both to the South and to Utah, and we are satisfied that ultimately the country will reach the conclusion here outlined.
Governor Murray, of Utah, represents to the General Government the uselessness of enacting laws against polygamy unless they are enforced. Governor Murray has lived in Utah, and yet he does not appear to have perceived the real nature of the difficulties with which Congress has to do. Between the conditions which obtain at the South, and those of Utah, there is no difference in essentials. In both cases it has been found impossible to enforce laws which are opposed by the public sentiment of the dominant elements of society. All history teaches that where this condition exists the imposition of obnoxious laws upon the community is impracticable without the employment of a degree of force which very few powers have ever been able to command, and the use of which in this country would be incompatible with republican principles. This is the truth, and this it is which has baffled Congress so long, and has blunted all the weapons it has tried against the Mormon institution. General Grant gave Reconstruction a full trial at the South, and when he went out of office he had to acknowledge that it was a complete failure. It was so because the Southern people were out of sympathy with the principles it was sought to enforce, and because they were out of sympathy with these principles the South is solid to-day. There is nothing to be done in such cases but to deprive the recalcitrant community of the powers of evil, and trust to example and education for a change of sentiment. This applies both to the South and to Utah, and we are satisfied that ultimately the country will reach the conclusion here outlined.
What sub-type of article is it?
Moral Or Religious
Legal Reform
Social Reform
What keywords are associated?
Polygamy
Utah
Enforcement
Public Sentiment
Reconstruction
South
Mormon Institution
Republican Principles
What entities or persons were involved?
Governor Murray
General Grant
Congress
Mormons
Southern People
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Challenges Enforcing Anti Polygamy Laws In Utah Versus Reconstruction In The South
Stance / Tone
Advocacy For Sentiment Change Over Forceful Enforcement
Key Figures
Governor Murray
General Grant
Congress
Mormons
Southern People
Key Arguments
Laws Against Polygamy Are Useless Without Enforcement
Public Sentiment Opposes Such Laws In Utah Like In The South
History Shows Imposement Of Obnoxious Laws Requires Excessive Force Incompatible With Republican Principles
Congress Has Failed To Suppress Mormon Institution Due To This
Reconstruction Failed At South Because Of Lack Of Sympathy With Enforced Principles
South Remains Solid Due To Unsympathetic Sentiment
Solution Is To Deprive Recalcitrant Communities Of Evil Powers And Rely On Example And Education