Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for New Hampshire Statesman And State Journal
Story June 18, 1836

New Hampshire Statesman And State Journal

Concord, Merrimack County, New Hampshire

What is this article about?

In New York, Richard Robinson is acquitted after a five-day trial for the murder of Ellen Jewett. Despite strong circumstantial evidence and witness identification, a partial alibi and evidence of other men entering the house create reasonable doubt, leading to cheers upon the verdict.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

ACQUITTAL OF ROBINSON.

The trial of Robinson, for the murder of Ellen Jewett, commenced in New-York on Thursday, Judge Edwards presiding. Much time was occupied in empannelling a jury. It excited a good deal of interest; the circumstantial evidence against him was very strong. Mr. Hoxie, his late employer, was seated at his side during the trial, and seemed to take a deep interest in his fate. Four witnesses were examined on Thursday, including Rosanna Townsend, at whose house the murder was committed, and whose evidence was positive as to the identity of Robinson coming into the house on the night of the murder.

A partial alibi was proved, by the testimony of a grocer, who sold Robinson some cigars late on the evening of the murder.

On the trial it was also clearly proved that many other men were let into the house that night, and that they went out in the midst of the alarm of fire and murder. This circumstance threw a reasonable doubt over what might otherwise have been condemnatory evidence.

The summing up of counsel on both sides continued until past twelve, Tuesday night. The Court then charged the Jury, who retired for about fifteen minutes, and returned into Court with a verdict of ACQUITTAL. The announcement of which was hailed with loud and boisterous cheers by the people in and outside the Court. When the verdict was pronounced Robinson, for the first time during the trial, exhibited signs of emotion, and burst into tears.—In a few minutes afterwards Robinson left the Court leaning on the arm of Mr. Hoxie.

The trial lasted five days.

What sub-type of article is it?

Crime Story Historical Event Mystery

What themes does it cover?

Crime Punishment Justice Fortune Reversal

What keywords are associated?

Murder Trial Acquittal Ellen Jewett Circumstantial Evidence Alibi New York Jury Verdict

What entities or persons were involved?

Robinson Ellen Jewett Judge Edwards Mr. Hoxie Rosanna Townsend

Where did it happen?

New York

Story Details

Key Persons

Robinson Ellen Jewett Judge Edwards Mr. Hoxie Rosanna Townsend

Location

New York

Event Date

Thursday To Tuesday, Five Days

Story Details

Robinson's trial for murdering Ellen Jewett at Rosanna Townsend's house features strong circumstantial evidence and witness identification, but a partial alibi from a grocer and proof of other men entering the house that night create doubt. After five days, the jury acquits him in fifteen minutes, eliciting cheers and Robinson's tears.

Are you sure?