Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for National Opinion
Domestic News May 19, 1871

National Opinion

Bradford, Orange County, Vermont

What is this article about?

Ferdinand Kohl and Charles H. Gardner sued Brooklyn Postmaster James Semler for $5,000 over retained letters, but the court ruled in Semler's favor after evidence showed the plaintiffs were swindlers operating under multiple names and failing to deliver goods after receiving payments.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

A Postmaster Sued By Swindlers.

Before Judge Benedict, in the United States Eastern District Court, Ferdinand Kohl and Charles H. Gardner, brought suit against James Semler, Postmaster at Brooklyn, N. Y., to recover $5,000 damages for letters retained addressed to them. The testimony showed that the plaintiffs were in the habit of flooding the country with circulars, setting forth that they could supply dry goods at much less than the regular market prices. The firm went under the name of Kohl & Co., Chapman & Co., and Hamilton & Co., and it was shown that, after receiving remittances, they neglected in many cases to forward the goods. The Postmaster received letters from persons in different parts of the country inquiring whether there was such a firm as Kohl & Co., in Williamsburg, and at last becoming convinced that they were swindlers he laid the matter before the Department at Washington, and was instructed to retain all letters for the firm, which he did. Plaintiffs then commenced this suit for damages, which resulted in a decision in favor of the Postmaster. - N. Y. Paper.

What sub-type of article is it?

Legal Or Court Crime

What keywords are associated?

Postmaster Lawsuit Mail Fraud Swindlers Brooklyn Court Retained Letters

What entities or persons were involved?

Ferdinand Kohl Charles H. Gardner James Semler Judge Benedict

Where did it happen?

Brooklyn, N. Y.

Domestic News Details

Primary Location

Brooklyn, N. Y.

Key Persons

Ferdinand Kohl Charles H. Gardner James Semler Judge Benedict

Outcome

decision in favor of the postmaster.

Event Details

Ferdinand Kohl and Charles H. Gardner sued Brooklyn Postmaster James Semler for $5,000 damages due to retained letters addressed to their firm. Testimony revealed they operated as swindlers under names like Kohl & Co., sending circulars for cheap dry goods, receiving payments but often not delivering. Semler, after inquiries and instructions from Washington, retained the letters, leading to the suit's dismissal in his favor.

Are you sure?