Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up freeRichmond Enquirer
Richmond, Richmond County, Virginia
What is this article about?
Humorous 1826 Virginia Senate debate on 'Crow bill' to bounty killing crows for protecting corn in Fairfax; poetic arguments on crop damage, amendments for other counties, crow diet, and economic effects.
OCR Quality
Full Text
The following sketch of a spirited debate which occurred in the Senate last winter pending the consideration of the Crow bill, was written at the time by a member; as a renewal of the debate is anticipated at the present session on the proposition lately submitted to the House of Delegates, to amend the bill, we have been induced to give publicity to the arguments then used, in the hope that such as design participating in the expected discussion, may derive some valuable hints from the labours of those who have preceded them.
[Winchester Virginian.]
DEBATE ON THE CROW BILL.
In the Senate of Virginia,
February 9, 1826.
-Crows and Choughs that wing the midway air
Show scarce.
-Shakspeare, King Lear,
Mr. McC.
By that bill, Mr. Speaker, 'tis meant to propose
The form of a law for the killing of crows;
A County requests us--the county Fairfax,
To place it as one in the list of our acts
In saie, Sir, that you avd that every one knows
How very destructive to corn are the Crows,
There is not perhaps any bird, Sir, that hops
That pulls up as much of the corn planter's crops;
They gather by thousands and tear with their bills
Each plant as it peeps through the top of the hills;
I see, Sir, this subject produces some mirth,
But let not a Crow, Sir, remain up on earth,
If the West is to pay for the wolf and its whelps
Why may not the East for the crow or its scalps?
I hope they, the Senate will pass, Sir, the law,
We wish not in Fairfax to hear a crow caw.
Mr. R.
Mr. Speaker, I move to amend the crow bill
By adding to those who have license to kill--
Insert after Fairfax the words "Isle of Wight,
Southampton and Surry" you also may write,
Tis not that I have--oh no, heaven knows,
A thirst, Mr. Speaker, for blood of the crows;
Prince George and the crows are on very good terms,
We want them to eat up that pest, the cut worms,
But some of my counties complain with Fairfax
And isn't it right they should come in for snack??
Mr. McC.
With this bill, Mr. Speaker, some wage down below
Are strongly suspected of "picking a crow."
Against this amendment, I therefore shall vote.
We might just as well catch the bill by the throat;
I will excite such a laugh in a certain great Hall
They'll scout from the House the amendment and all--
I hope, Sir, the bill will be then let alone,
This amendment will cause it to die with a groan.
Mr. P.
Mr. Speaker!!! I hope the amendment and bill
Will find in the Senate no jot of good will-.
To hold out a bounty in any such case
Is simply rewarding the vagrant and base;
From labour productive 'tis taking away, Sir.
Your hundreds to idle and waste all the day, Sir;
Instead of promoting the true wealth of nations
Is taking men off from their suitable stations,
From digging from grubbing and other hard blows,
To shooting their guns at a parcel of crows.
But Sir, I assert it--'tis true on my word,
The crow is in fact a carnivorous bird;
He doesn't like corn Sir--he wouldn't eat grain,
He'd strut by the thing on a bit of disdain;
If he only could get flesh enough for his turn,
What you think is his passion, he'd caw at and spurn;
'Tis mere "Hobson's choice," with him when his scorn,
Is seen to relax, and he gobbles your corn.
I would ask too the member who urges this tax,
If it be not unwise in the county Fairfax?
If the end is effected, this crow bill enforces,
What is to become of his mass of dead horses?
Mr. Ca.
It may seem Mr. Speaker, To some of the counties
To be a small matter, this granting of bounties;
But long have I thought, Sir, 'twould be very wise
In planters, some plan of the kind to devise.
The interests of husbandry, calling now louder,
Must have something stronger, than smell of gunpowder;
These birds come upon us like hordes, Sir, of Huns
And take care to keep out of range of our guns;
Some people have tried a contrivance we know
Which all have consented to call a scare-crow;
But I've seen 'em light on it with great nonchalance
And hopping about as if learning to dance.
A plan I once thought of, I'll freely disclose,
Twas to grant, Sir, a pension to each of these crows,
If I gave them as much of my corn as they'd eat
I thought that to steal it, would not be so sweet;
But alas, Mr. Speaker, they'll just as soon go
To the corn you have planted as that which you sow.
I own, Sir, farm in the old Northern Neck
Where crows would outnumber the grains which they peck,
And unless some provision is made in our laws
I fear, Sir, the planter must give up his cause.
Mr.R.
Although, Mr. Speaker, I moved that three counties
Should also partake of these ruinous bounties
I did it alone from a sense of my duty,
And not that I saw in the scheme any beauty,
What the gentleman said who was last on the floor
In the truth of my dogmas, but rivets me more;
The plan of a pension we've heard him rehearse
He proved like the poor lass an infinite curse.
His system, Sir, failing, conclusively shows
It swells but the number of paupers and crows
Malthus and others have proved that such laws
Increase but the cramming of bellies and craws.
I, therefore, shall vote, Sir, against the whole bill.
And I wish that the Senate would help me to kill.
Mr.J.
That he, Mr. Speaker, proposes to tax
All who reside in that county Fair-fax,
The grower of corn and he who grows none:
Tis wrong, Sir, injustice like this should be done.
Mr. F.
A law about wolves, Mr. Speaker's been made
And a tax on the county requesting it, laid.
The man who grows wool and the man who does not
Are surely involved in a similar lot.
The principle here is the same, Sir, I trow,
If you tax for the wolf, you may tax for the crow.
Mr. S
A single remark, Mr. Speaker. the man
Who doesn't make corn, eats bread if he can.
The more that is made, the cheaper he buys
Then doesn't he profit when any crow dies?
The Speaker arose from his arm chair at last
And ask'd if the bill in his hand should be passed.
And the "ayes" seemed to have it, he said, by the sound,
And the foes of the crows, how they crowed on the ground:!
Feb.10.
We hasten to notice an error we fell in
Reporting this bill, as regards Mr. A-
That gentleman moved an amendment, to wit.
If laws on the subject were thought at all fit,
Those laws should be general, and each county court
In its wisdom, to scalping of crows, might resort;
He thought that a body so grave as the Senate
Should not have a thing like a crow bill within it;
If the bill should go through with its one-sided features
Then year after year we should hear of these creatures
'Twas best in his judgment to deal such a blow,
As would shut up forever the bill of the crow;
And this was the speech which gave Mr. R.
What Fairfax would call, a fit of "humgruffin"
He had no objection he said to the bill-
As regards other counties--enact what you will;
But as for his county, he warmly protested
By bell, book and candle, if crows were molested
The worms there would fearlessly riot and revel-
All chance of a crop would be sent to the devil."
What sub-type of article is it?
What themes does it cover?
What keywords are associated?
What entities or persons were involved?
Where did it happen?
Story Details
Key Persons
Location
Senate Of Virginia
Event Date
February 9, 1826
Story Details
A satirical poetic debate in the Virginia Senate on a bill to legalize and bounty the killing of crows to protect corn crops in Fairfax County, with members arguing for and against, proposing amendments to include other counties, and debating the crow's diet and economic impacts.