Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Richmond Enquirer
Story May 22, 1816

Richmond Enquirer

Richmond, Richmond County, Virginia

What is this article about?

In January 1813, Lt. William Tisdale lost a pocketbook containing about $500 near Franklinton, Ohio. John Sells found it but refused to return it, demanding a description of a non-existent string. After legal delays, a 1815 trial in Franklin County resulted in a $500 verdict for Tisdale.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

Columbus, (O.) May 2.
RETRIBUTION.

Justice, though sometimes slow in its progress, is always unerring in its results. The wretch, whose craft and chicanery for a while counterpoises the sacred scale, will ultimately be divested of the sable shroud of subtlety, and stand, in his native deformity before an honest public.

The above remark is elucidated by a decision in the Court of Common Pleas of this county on Tuesday last.

In January, 1813, Lieut. William Tisdale, of the Petersburg volunteers, (a corps proverbial for their patriotism and bravery) then at Franklinton, lost his pocket book in a deep snow, near the Court-House.—Some three or four months afterwards, a certain John Sells, of Washington township, in this county, cautiously revealed to some of his connections and others, that he had found a pocket-book containing about five hundred dollars in paper and gold, nearly the amount, and the same description of money, lost by Mr. Tisdale.—The circumstance was whispered from one to another, until it became notorious. In the succeeding August, Mr. Sells, in the plenitude of his honesty, advertised the Pocket-Book in a public paper, without even a common description. After the siege of Fort Meigs, Mr. Tisdale called on Mr. Sells for his property. Mr. Sells replied, that if the Lieut. could describe the string on the Pocket Book, then in his possession, he would surrender it. This was impossible. Mr. Tisdale told him his Pocket Book never had a string; it was otherwise fastened, which was amply proved by Mr. Calvert Steuart, who travelled to this country with Mr. Tisdale.—Prosecution was commenced. The delays of law naturally intervened, till, at our present court a thorough investigation was had - Almost every attorney at the bar, incensed at the knavish conduct of Sells, volunteered in behalf of the absent unfortunate, and after patiently hearing a detail of strong circumstantial testimony, the jury, as honest, intelligent and independent as ever this county witnessed, brought in a most righteous verdict of FIVE HUNDRED DOLLARS for the plaintiff.

The very able and respectable counsel for defendant, were, we presume, so petrified at the baseness of their client, that they did not utter a word, and could scarcely groan in his defense.

During the examination some of the most respectable characters of the county, were called on, who testified that during the last three or four years they had not heard of the loss of any other pocket book containing money, except the one in question.

What sub-type of article is it?

Crime Story Deception Fraud Historical Event

What themes does it cover?

Crime Punishment Justice Moral Virtue

What keywords are associated?

Pocketbook Theft Court Trial Justice Verdict Deception Trick 1813 Loss

What entities or persons were involved?

William Tisdale John Sells Calvert Steuart

Where did it happen?

Franklin County, Ohio (Near Franklinton And Washington Township)

Story Details

Key Persons

William Tisdale John Sells Calvert Steuart

Location

Franklin County, Ohio (Near Franklinton And Washington Township)

Event Date

January 1813 (Loss); May 1815 (Trial)

Story Details

Lt. William Tisdale lost a pocketbook with $500 in January 1813 near Franklinton. John Sells found it months later, advertised it vaguely, and refused return demanding description of a non-existent string. Prosecution led to a 1815 trial where circumstantial evidence and witness testimony resulted in a $500 verdict for Tisdale.

Are you sure?