Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Virginia Gazette
Letter to Editor November 28, 1771

The Virginia Gazette

Richmond, Williamsburg, Richmond County, Virginia

What is this article about?

A correspondent critiques the excessive damages (2,000 pounds) awarded to James Otis against customs commissioner Ebenezer Robinson in Boston for an assault, attributing it to anti-British prejudice among colonists. Details the incident where Otis insulted Robinson, who struck back alone, and predicts the verdict will be overturned on appeal to Britain due to the disproportionate fine.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

From the excessive Damages given in Mr. Otis's Case (says the same Correspondent) at Boston (two Thousand Pounds Sterling being scarcely ever granted before for a mere Assault) the Impatience of the Bostonians may be easily discovered under the just Supremacy of the Mother Country.

Mr. Robinson was a Commissioner of the Customs at Boston, and distinguished himself remarkably by his spirited Endeavours to enforce the commercial Laws of England. This Conduct, though highly meritorious on our Side of the Atlantick, made him generally obnoxious to the Babes of Grace in New England; in Consequence of which Mr. Otis, it has been asserted, publickly insulted him, and Mr. Robinson chastised the Insolence as publickly, in the Coffeehouse.

To qualify the Disgrace of their Leader, under such a Castigation, the Saints gave out that Mr. Robinson was assisted by others in belabouring poor Otis. The contrary, however, was the Fact, as appears by the Publications of the Period. Mr. Robinson only struck Mr. Otis; but several, in the Course of the Scuffle, struck Mr. Robinson.

It is generally imagined, that, upon a Hearing of the Matter before an impartial Judicature, the mere Circumstance of Excess in the Damages will be a sufficient Ground to annul the whole Proceedings. The Inadequacy of the Offence to the Fine proclaims how much Prejudice operated in the Verdict; and the Moderation of the Plaintiff may be easily determined, who appeals to this Kingdom for another Thousand Pounds.

What sub-type of article is it?

Historical Informative Political

What themes does it cover?

Politics Crime Punishment

What keywords are associated?

Otis Case Boston Assault Customs Enforcement Colonial Prejudice British Supremacy Damages Verdict

Letter to Editor Details

Main Argument

the excessive damages awarded to otis against robinson in boston reflect colonial prejudice against british authority and enforcement of customs laws; the verdict is disproportionate and likely to be annulled on appeal to britain.

Notable Details

Robinson Struck Otis Alone, Contrary To Claims Of Assistance Otis Appeals For Additional 1,000 Pounds References Publications Of The Period Confirming Facts

Are you sure?