Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Vermont Telegraph
Editorial October 9, 1839

Vermont Telegraph

Brandon, Rutland County, Vermont

What is this article about?

Editorial criticizing the harsh corporal punishment of eight lashes given to a young marine for his first offense of staying out overnight with his wife, as reported from Philadelphia World. Argues for enforcing discipline without brutality and abolishing corporeal punishment under U.S. laws.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

Cruelty. We learn from the Philadelphia World, that a young man, a marine attached to the navy yard, stayed out of the yard a few nights since, with his wife during the night—contrary to the rules of the service. He returned to his duty in the morning, but although it was his first offence, he was punished by order of the officer on duty, with eight lashes on his bare back with the cat! The rules of discipline should be enforced—but we verily believe this may be done without such acts of brutal tyranny as related above. Corporeal punishment should not be recognized by the United States' laws. It is time that this degrading mode of punishment—this system of torturing a man into the performance of a duty should be abolished under an enlightened government—Boston Journal.

What sub-type of article is it?

Crime Or Punishment Military Affairs Social Reform

What keywords are associated?

Corporal Punishment Navy Discipline Brutal Tyranny Penal Reform Military Cruelty

What entities or persons were involved?

Philadelphia World Navy Yard Officer United States' Laws Boston Journal

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Opposition To Corporal Punishment In The Navy

Stance / Tone

Strongly Against Brutal Corporal Punishment

Key Figures

Philadelphia World Navy Yard Officer United States' Laws Boston Journal

Key Arguments

First Offense Punished With Eight Lashes On Bare Back Discipline Can Be Enforced Without Brutal Tyranny Corporeal Punishment Is Degrading And Should Be Abolished Torturing For Duty Performance Unfit For Enlightened Government

Are you sure?