Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Mitchell Capital
Editorial August 19, 1887

The Mitchell Capital

Mitchell, Davison County, South Dakota

What is this article about?

Editorial critiques the efficacy of mind or faith cures, acknowledging their success in some nervous disorders but arguing they are powerless against physical ailments, attributing their popularity to public ignorance and charlatanism. Mentions a physician's successful treatment method for nervousness.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

The Mind or Faith Cure.

We must admit that there are cases well authenticated where the so called mind or faith cure does what medicine could not accomplish. These are certain nervous troubles that the mind directly influences. For instance, a woman will sometimes become bedridden, entirely devoid of the power of motion, when the action of her heart, liver and vital organs is normal. Drugs will do her no good. The faith doctor will come along, give her a nervous shock, and she is cured. Then everybody will be told of the miraculous event, and the faith doctor will pretend to cure everything, from rheumatism to colic. But, outside of a few nervous phenomena, the mind doctor is powerless. He is out of his element when he tries a physical cure. Faith cannot cure a fever any more than medicine would cure a wound. Charlatanism flourishes because ignorant people fail to distinguish between nervous and physical disorders. There is a famous physician who treats these purely nervous cases in a peculiar and successful way. He shuts them in a dark room for some weeks, and, as their digestion is good, overfeeds them, and by a fattening process entirely overcomes nervousness. Doctor In Globe-Democrat.

What sub-type of article is it?

Science Or Medicine Social Reform

What keywords are associated?

Faith Cure Mind Cure Nervous Disorders Physical Ailments Charlatanism Medical Skepticism

What entities or persons were involved?

Faith Doctor Mind Doctor Famous Physician Doctor In Globe Democrat

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Limitations Of Mind Or Faith Cure

Stance / Tone

Skeptical Critique Of Faith Healing

Key Figures

Faith Doctor Mind Doctor Famous Physician Doctor In Globe Democrat

Key Arguments

Mind Or Faith Cures Succeed Only In Nervous Troubles Influenced By The Mind. They Fail For Physical Disorders Like Fever Or Wounds. Charlatanism Thrives Due To Ignorance Distinguishing Nervous From Physical Issues. A Famous Physician Cures Nervousness By Isolation, Overfeeding, And Fattening.

Are you sure?