Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
March 26, 1871
The Morning Star And Catholic Messenger
New Orleans, Orleans County, Louisiana
What is this article about?
The editorial ridicules Protestant religious newspapers, including the South-western Presbyterian, for falling for a hoax papal bull excommunicating Victor Emmanuel, which was actually a fictional excerpt from Tristram Shandy republished in Pomeroy's Democrat for amusement. It notes the bull's prior exposure by Archbishop Hughes.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
We were much amused some time ago in reading in the so-called religious press--and among them the South-western Presbyterian of this city, a "Bull" from the Pope, excommunicating Victor Emmanuel. As a consequence, Popery was denounced by Protestants as an outrage on human rights. Most of the sectarian papers believed in it, and bellowed indignantly at the outrage. The same "Bull" has been published before, especially in Know-Nothing times, and was exposed by Archbishop Hughes, when vouched for by a Princeton Professor.
It now appears that Pomeroy's Democrat, for amusement, copied the "Bull" from Tristram Shandy, and those papers which are ever ready to publish everything, no matter how false, of the Catholic Church, strongly advocated the dethronement of the Pope. Pomeroy enjoyed the joke, whilst he also enjoyed the profits from a large sale of his paper. The fools are not all dead yet.
The following is to the point:
Excommunicating Victor Emmanuel.--A few weeks since we published the fictitious anathema of the Catholic Church, written by the Rev. Lawrence Sterne, taken from the novel of "Tristram Shandy," chapter 2, volume 3d, prefaced by a paragraph devoting it to Victor Emmanuel, when, just as we expected, several of the smart daily newspapers copied the article under the head of
Foreign News
as to copy it under the head of "Telegraphic Despatches from Rome." Some editors are very sharp, but not sharp enough to distinguish between an improbable burlesque and an established fact.
It now appears that Pomeroy's Democrat, for amusement, copied the "Bull" from Tristram Shandy, and those papers which are ever ready to publish everything, no matter how false, of the Catholic Church, strongly advocated the dethronement of the Pope. Pomeroy enjoyed the joke, whilst he also enjoyed the profits from a large sale of his paper. The fools are not all dead yet.
The following is to the point:
Excommunicating Victor Emmanuel.--A few weeks since we published the fictitious anathema of the Catholic Church, written by the Rev. Lawrence Sterne, taken from the novel of "Tristram Shandy," chapter 2, volume 3d, prefaced by a paragraph devoting it to Victor Emmanuel, when, just as we expected, several of the smart daily newspapers copied the article under the head of
Foreign News
as to copy it under the head of "Telegraphic Despatches from Rome." Some editors are very sharp, but not sharp enough to distinguish between an improbable burlesque and an established fact.
What sub-type of article is it?
Satire
Moral Or Religious
What keywords are associated?
Papal Bull Hoax
Religious Press
Anti Catholic Bias
Tristram Shandy
Victor Emmanuel
Pomeroy Democrat
What entities or persons were involved?
Pope
Victor Emmanuel
Archbishop Hughes
Pomeroy's Democrat
South Western Presbyterian
Tristram Shandy
Princeton Professor
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Hoax Papal Bull Fooling Religious Press
Stance / Tone
Amused Mockery Of Protestant Gullibility
Key Figures
Pope
Victor Emmanuel
Archbishop Hughes
Pomeroy's Democrat
South Western Presbyterian
Tristram Shandy
Princeton Professor
Key Arguments
Religious Press Denounced A Fictional Papal Bull As Real
The Bull Originated From Tristram Shandy And Was Republished As A Hoax
It Was Previously Exposed During Know Nothing Times
Papers Eagerly Publish False Anti Catholic Stories
Editors Failed To Distinguish Burlesque From Fact