Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
March 6, 1892
Arizona Republican
Phoenix, Maricopa County, Arizona
What is this article about?
Editorial argues for placing the Indian Bureau under the War Department instead of the Interior Department, appointing army officers as agents, criticizing Commissioner Morgan's incompetence, and highlighting benefits like better education and order, citing the successful Carlisle school under Captain Pratt.
OCR Quality
95%
Excellent
Full Text
INDIANS AND THE ARMY.
It is probable that the Indian appropriation bill, when it leaves the House and goes to the Senate, will contain a clause authorizing the president to appoint army officers as Indian agents.
These officers would, while acting as agents, be under the authority of the interior department.
The provision is a move in the right direction, but it does not go far enough. It aims to secure the services of competent men as Indian agents, but it would leave those men under the control of the incompetent chief of the Indian bureau.
The entire Indian bureau should be placed under the care of the army. In other words, it ought to be taken away from the department of the interior and given to the war department.
There is no work connected with the Indians which the war department could not do better than the interior department is doing it now. It would be next to impossible for so incompetent a man as Commissioner Morgan to secure the place of chief of the bureau if it were attached to the war department.
Bigotry and general inefficiency would not characterize the administration of the bureau. The education of the Indian children would be attended to in a better way than at present, for the entire administration of Indian affairs would be in better hands than it is now.
Whatever may be said of the results of the education of the Indian children at the Carlisle school, it cannot be denied that the school itself is well conducted. It is under the direction of Captain Pratt of the regular army.
If all Indian agencies were under the care of army officers, there would be no more trouble with the Indians on account of a scarcity of food and good clothing, unless congress failed to make the requisite appropriations. The system and order which would characterize the administration of Indian affairs would prevent the complications which from time to time arise at Indian agencies under the present method of governing them.
It is probable that the Indian appropriation bill, when it leaves the House and goes to the Senate, will contain a clause authorizing the president to appoint army officers as Indian agents.
These officers would, while acting as agents, be under the authority of the interior department.
The provision is a move in the right direction, but it does not go far enough. It aims to secure the services of competent men as Indian agents, but it would leave those men under the control of the incompetent chief of the Indian bureau.
The entire Indian bureau should be placed under the care of the army. In other words, it ought to be taken away from the department of the interior and given to the war department.
There is no work connected with the Indians which the war department could not do better than the interior department is doing it now. It would be next to impossible for so incompetent a man as Commissioner Morgan to secure the place of chief of the bureau if it were attached to the war department.
Bigotry and general inefficiency would not characterize the administration of the bureau. The education of the Indian children would be attended to in a better way than at present, for the entire administration of Indian affairs would be in better hands than it is now.
Whatever may be said of the results of the education of the Indian children at the Carlisle school, it cannot be denied that the school itself is well conducted. It is under the direction of Captain Pratt of the regular army.
If all Indian agencies were under the care of army officers, there would be no more trouble with the Indians on account of a scarcity of food and good clothing, unless congress failed to make the requisite appropriations. The system and order which would characterize the administration of Indian affairs would prevent the complications which from time to time arise at Indian agencies under the present method of governing them.
What sub-type of article is it?
Indian Affairs
Military Affairs
What keywords are associated?
Indian Agents
Army Officers
Indian Bureau
War Department
Interior Department
Commissioner Morgan
Carlisle School
Indian Education
Indian Affairs Administration
What entities or persons were involved?
Army Officers
Indian Bureau
Commissioner Morgan
Captain Pratt
Carlisle School
War Department
Interior Department
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Transfer Of Indian Bureau To War Department
Stance / Tone
Advocacy For Army Administration Of Indian Affairs
Key Figures
Army Officers
Indian Bureau
Commissioner Morgan
Captain Pratt
Carlisle School
War Department
Interior Department
Key Arguments
Authorize President To Appoint Army Officers As Indian Agents Under Interior Department
Provision Does Not Go Far Enough; Entire Indian Bureau Should Be Under War Department
War Department Would Handle Indian Affairs Better Than Interior Department
Incompetent Commissioner Morgan Would Not Lead If Under War Department
Army Administration Would Eliminate Bigotry And Inefficiency
Improve Education Of Indian Children
Carlisle School Well Conducted Under Army Captain Pratt
Army Oversight Would Prevent Agency Troubles If Appropriations Sufficient