Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Alexandria Gazette
Letter to Editor July 10, 1854

Alexandria Gazette

Alexandria, Alexandria County, District Of Columbia

What is this article about?

A farmer from Culpeper County responds to recommendations in the Gazette, arguing that Guano, while valuable for vegetation, does not prevent joint worm or rust in wheat crops. He emphasizes that early seeding without Guano is preferable to late seeding with it, warning against over-reliance on Guano at high prices.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

COMMUNICATED.

In a recent number of the Gazette, I notice a communication from Mr. John Marshall, in which he concurs with Mr. Noland, in recommending a free use of Guano as the most practicable means of getting rid of the ravages of the joint worm. "Mr. M. adds, that in the joint worm infected region it is more than useless to sow any kind of Wheat without Guano. The gentleman, surely, would have us believe that Guano is the sine qua non to the profitable production of Wheat."

No one, I imagine, can be found at this advanced period of the use of Guano, to doubt its astonishing and valuable effects on vegetation of all kinds. Powerful and valuable as it is, I do not think, there is any considerable number of farmers concurring in the opinions above quoted, as it is a fact known to hundreds, in the County of Culpeper, that a free use of Guano will not insure against the depredations of the joint worm or fly, or save it from rust, if seeded late; indeed, "the crops of wheat on some land, the present season, are so bad, notwithstanding Guano was freely used, (while those on fallow, early seeded, without Guano, yielded well.) the opinion prevails, that early seeding, regardless of variety, has more to do with the successful raising of Wheat, than a free use of Guano."

Consequently, they greatly prefer early seeding without Guano, to late or corn land seeding with it.

In conclusion, I would respectfully suggest to those who are likely to be induced to purchase Guano at the unreasonable rates, at which it is at present held, under the belief that an antidote has at last been discovered for the joint worm, not to lay the flattering unction to their souls, for most assuredly will they be disappointed.

A FARMER.

Culpeper County, July 8, 1854.

What sub-type of article is it?

Persuasive Informative

What themes does it cover?

Agriculture

What keywords are associated?

Guano Joint Worm Wheat Production Early Seeding Culpeper County Rust Prevention

What entities or persons were involved?

A Farmer

Letter to Editor Details

Author

A Farmer

Main Argument

guano is valuable for vegetation but does not prevent joint worm, fly, or rust in wheat, especially if seeded late; early seeding without guano is more effective for successful wheat production than late seeding with it.

Notable Details

References Communication From Mr. John Marshall Concurring With Mr. Noland Observations From Culpeper County On Wheat Crops This Season Quotes On Poor Yields Despite Guano Use Versus Good Yields From Early Seeding Without It

Are you sure?