Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Liberator
Letter to Editor October 12, 1838

The Liberator

Boston, Suffolk County, Massachusetts

What is this article about?

A letter criticizes Rev. Elipha White, a South Carolina slaveholder and advocate of 'Christian slavery,' for hypocritically preaching the Golden Rule in a Boston church, questioning his consistency and whether he would deliver the same sermon to slaves or a Southern audience.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

THE PULPIT DESECRATED ANEW
Mr. Editor:
Recently on a Sabbath morning, as I entered the church where I usually worship, I observed in the desk the Rev. ELIPHA WHITE, of South Carolina, a reputed slaveholder, or, at least, a bold and zealous advocate of christian slavery upon gospel principles. At first, I confess that I was at a loss to conjecture how such a man, with such professed principles, could have the effrontery to stand up and address a Boston audience as a christian minister. But reflecting that many of the clergy in the United States consider slavery to be a divine institution, I concluded that this was one of those instances, where 'popular crime,' however flagrant, 'does not disturb the conscience;' and became prepared during the preparatory exercises, to hear a common-place discourse. You may judge, however, of my surprise, when the Rev. Slavite announced for his text the Golden Rule: All things whatsoever,' &c. What! thought I, has he been listening, during his visit to the North the present season, to the pleadings of bleeding humanity, to examine the precepts of our Saviour, and has he so far yielded to their manifest teachings, as to renounce his former barbarous theory—ay, and practice too? The discourse was such an one, as no abolitionist would object to, though it possessed but very little of that spice of intellect, which is always acceptable in all preaching, in order to give it a relish. He was particular in stating that the words of his text enjoined that the scriptures should be given, and the gospel preached to every human being, (and to quote his own language) to the farthest verge of this green earth;' for this was just what, and no more, than all Christians would wish to be done to them.
Query. Does he consider slaves human beings? Certainly, they live on this 'green earth.' I should be glad to inquire of the Rev. slaveholder, or of some of his friends, whether he would be willing to preach that sermon before an enlightened audience of slaves, or whether he would dare preach it before a South Carolina congregation, and urge, with the emphasis that he did in this city, the imperious duty of Christians to furnish the Bible to every individual of the human family?
CONSISTENCY.

What sub-type of article is it?

Persuasive Provocative Ethical Moral

What themes does it cover?

Slavery Abolition Religion Morality

What keywords are associated?

Slavery Abolition Hypocrisy Golden Rule Christian Slavery Elipha White Boston Church South Carolina

What entities or persons were involved?

Consistency Mr. Editor

Letter to Editor Details

Author

Consistency

Recipient

Mr. Editor

Main Argument

criticizes rev. elipha white for hypocritically preaching the golden rule, which implies preaching the gospel to all humans including slaves, while being a slaveholder and advocate of slavery on christian principles.

Notable Details

  • quotes the golden rule as text
  • refers to minister as 'rev. slavite'
  • questions if slaves are considered human beings
  • highlights potential difference in preaching to slaves or southern audience

Are you sure?