Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for New York Dispatch
Editorial September 22, 1878

New York Dispatch

New York, New York County, New York

What is this article about?

An editorial condemns Recorder Hackett's recent improper actions on the New York Court of General Sessions bench, including threatening to shoot a convicted thief, roughly handling a witness, and criticizing the press that aided his election.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

RECORDER HACKETT.

Recorder Hackett has recently conducted himself on the bench of the Court of General Sessions in a manner that has excited the just surprise of our citizens. On Wednesday a boy of sixteen was convicted before the Recorder of the theft of a gold watch, whereupon Hackett, raising his voice to its highest pitch, declared that if anybody tried to rob him on a street car, he would promptly shoot him dead. Now, Mr. Recorder, what sort of law is that? If you killed a pickpocket that committed no violence upon you, you would be guilty of the crime of manslaughter. Such statements made by a Judge on the bench are not only foolish in the extreme, but they should not pass without official animadversion. On the preceding day the Recorder had collared a witness, shaken him furiously, and roared at him that if he would not tell the truth, he should be punished severely for contempt of court. Previously, the Recorder had repeatedly and most ungratefully abused the newspapers of New York, to whose energetic support he was principally indebted for his election. Let him bear in mind that the press, which made him what he is, will not permit him to act on the bench as he has recently done without letting the public know of his shortcomings.

What sub-type of article is it?

Legal Reform

What keywords are associated?

Recorder Hackett Judicial Misconduct Court Conduct New York Press Witness Treatment

What entities or persons were involved?

Recorder Hackett Court Of General Sessions Newspapers Of New York

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Criticism Of Recorder Hackett's Judicial Conduct

Stance / Tone

Strongly Critical

Key Figures

Recorder Hackett Court Of General Sessions Newspapers Of New York

Key Arguments

Hackett's Declaration To Shoot A Thief Would Constitute Manslaughter Judge's Threats From The Bench Are Foolish And Warrant Official Rebuke Hackett Improperly Collared And Threatened A Witness For Contempt Hackett Ungratefully Abused The Press That Supported His Election

Are you sure?