Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up freeDaily Cincinnati Republican
Cincinnati, Hamilton County, Ohio
What is this article about?
An editorial from the N.Y. Sun criticizes journals, especially the American, for misrepresenting the Creole case to portray the U.S. as wrong. It defends Secretary Webster's position that British authorities unjustly freed mutinous slaves on the ship, arguing for indemnity rather than war, and highlights true U.S.-British tensions over naval freedom.
OCR Quality
Full Text
Foremost among these journals is the American, which has not only published many long columns upon the Creole case, but not content with leaving its calumnies to the short life of newspaper articles, it has embodied them in a book. And what does it all amount to? Why, it falsely assumes that Mr. Webster had given instructions to Mr. Everett to demand the surrender of the slaves engaged in the mutiny on board the Creole. It also falsely assumes that the slaves escaped without any unlawful interference on the part of the British authorities. It then goes on upon these premises to show that our government has no right to make any such demand, and that we are about to go to war in a case where we are wholly in the wrong. The same cry is caught up and echoed from all the papers of a similar character, and hands are uplifted in holy horror at the idea of our going to war in such a cause.
Now, as we have said, these assumptions are totally unfounded from first to last. Mr. Webster says in his despatch, in effect, that the slaves were freed by the unjustifiable interference of the British authorities, and in consequence of their withholding from the vessel the kind offices to which by the comity of nations she was entitled. It is therefore, he contends, a case for indemnity, but no demand for the return of the slaves is made, or even hinted at, and so the whole argument of the American tumbles to the ground, like a useless fabric.
And as to going to war about it in any shape, nobody has ever thought of that, except those who attempt to force a false issue upon the country for the sake of putting it in the wrong. Our true causes of quarrel lie farther over than any that would be raised by a hundred Creole cases. Britannia is determined to rule the waves—'COLUMBIA SWEARS THEY SHALL BE FREE!' This is the true and only gist about which there will be any fighting.—N. Y. Sun.
What sub-type of article is it?
What keywords are associated?
What entities or persons were involved?
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Defense Against Misrepresentations Of The Creole Case
Stance / Tone
Patriotic Defense Of U.S. Position Against Abolitionist Journals
Key Figures
Key Arguments