Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Virginian
Domestic News January 28, 1823

The Virginian

Lynchburg, Virginia

What is this article about?

During a U.S. Senate debate on a bill allowing drawback on exported cordage from foreign hemp, Mr. Dickerson criticized Mr. Lloyd's merchant perspective, prompting a warm response from Mr. Smith of Maryland defending merchants' integrity.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

A SENATORIAL SCENE.

During the late debate in the Senate of the United States, on the bill respecting allowing a drawback on the exportation of cordage manufactured from foreign hemp, after Mr. Lloyd had finished speaking in an instructive and senatorial manner, "Mr. Dickerson thought that the argument of a merchant (alluding to the gentleman who preceded him) ought not to have so much weight as that of an unprejudiced legislator." Mr. Smith, of Md. asked if it was proper for a real statesman to make such a reply, as the gentleman from New Jersey had done, to say "that his was the argument of a merchant." I have listened to the arguments of the gentleman from Massachusetts with great pleasure, and I fully subscribe to all he has said, both in relation to the trade with Russia and the proposed measure. The honorable gentleman particularly emphasised the word "merchant." It struck my ear, said Mr. S. very unpleasantly—What, sir, is the argument of a merchant to have no weight? Have merchants no information or integrity? Mr. Smith replied with considerable warmth to Mr. D. who, he thought, had not acted the part of a true legislator, in the course of his observations.

[N. Y. Com. Adv.

What sub-type of article is it?

Politics

What keywords are associated?

Senate Debate Cordage Bill Merchant Argument Dickerson Smith Lloyd

What entities or persons were involved?

Mr. Lloyd Mr. Dickerson Mr. Smith Of Md. Gentleman From Massachusetts Gentleman From New Jersey

Where did it happen?

United States Senate

Domestic News Details

Primary Location

United States Senate

Event Date

During The Late Debate

Key Persons

Mr. Lloyd Mr. Dickerson Mr. Smith Of Md. Gentleman From Massachusetts Gentleman From New Jersey

Event Details

In the Senate debate on a bill for drawback on exported cordage from foreign hemp, Mr. Dickerson remarked that a merchant's argument (referring to Mr. Lloyd) should carry less weight than an unprejudiced legislator's. Mr. Smith of Maryland responded warmly, questioning the propriety of such a statement and defending merchants' information and integrity.

Are you sure?