Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Daily National Intelligencer
Story November 15, 1816

Daily National Intelligencer

Washington, District Of Columbia

What is this article about?

New York State Prison Inspectors address legislature on overcrowding and propose transporting serious felons to a northwest American colony or state frontier to enhance punishment and utility, amid concerns of demoralization.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

A Novel Proposition.

The Inspectors of the State Prison of New-York, in an address to the Legislature, through the Governor of the State, lament the excess of numbers condemned to the Penitentiary, which makes frequent pardons indispensable, and otherwise detracts from the utility of the institution. They then proceed thus:-

"With these facts before us, it has become matter of serious consideration whether the state prison has not a tendency to demoralise rather than to reclaim criminals; for whenever punishment is so far mitigated as not to be dreaded, the law fails in the effect it proposes to produce. We are, therefore, firmly of opinion, that some different plan for the punishment of crimes of the first magnitude, such as arson, forgery and other felonies of the deepest die, ought to be adopted, or a state prison in every district will be required to contain the delinquents. Permit us, then, to suggest to your excellency and the honorable the legislature, the propriety of recommending, through our representatives in congress, the establishment, by the general government, of a colony on the north west coast of America, at or near the Columbia River, or at Madison Island, to which convicts of the aforementioned class shall be transported. If, however, the government of the United States should object to this plan, why may not this state adopt a similar one, on a smaller scale, and fix on some place on the frontiers of the state, where they may be sent and usefully employed, to keep them from committing, in future, their depredations on society? Believing that the utility as well as the necessity of some distant place being fixed upon to which certain convicts in the different states of the union may be transported will be generally acknowledged by congress, we feel anxious that the subject should be submitted to their consideration as early as possible."

What sub-type of article is it?

Historical Event

What themes does it cover?

Crime Punishment Justice

What keywords are associated?

Prison Overcrowding Convict Transportation Penal Colony New York Prison Felony Punishment

What entities or persons were involved?

Inspectors Of The State Prison Of New York

Where did it happen?

State Prison Of New York

Story Details

Key Persons

Inspectors Of The State Prison Of New York

Location

State Prison Of New York

Story Details

Inspectors lament prison overcrowding necessitating pardons, question its reformative effect, and propose transporting serious criminals like arsonists and forgers to a federal colony near Columbia River or Madison Island, or a state frontier site for useful employment.

Are you sure?