Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Gazette Of The United States, & Philadelphia Daily Advertiser
Letter to Editor September 18, 1797

Gazette Of The United States, & Philadelphia Daily Advertiser

Philadelphia, Philadelphia County, Pennsylvania

What is this article about?

A letter to Mr. Fenno critiques excessive bloodletting in medicine, arguing that reported successes ignore the many deaths from such practices, compares practitioners to robbers, and demands publication of cure-to-death ratios for comparison with alternative systems.

Clipping

OCR Quality

75% Good

Full Text

MR. FENNO,

What purpose can any man expect to answer by informing us that 40 men have been found, whom it was impracticable to bleed to death? Reverse the card, and what figure does this number of names make alongside the black list of victims to similar wanton experiments on human life? But the bleeding gentry know they have an advantage, and have all along sedulously improved it--They know it would not do for any one to come forward and say, that such and such men died by excessive bleeding: such a thing would not be borne--and yet perhaps the individual who is capable of perpetrating such atrocities in pursuit of a favorite system, is little better than he who bleeds you for your purse on the highway.

I am confident, nevertheless, that it is the only effectual way to silence those clamorous and prating satellites of this grand panacea. Let the disciples of blood publish statements of the number of their cures and the proportion, that we may contrast them with those of the other system. What is it to me that any man is carried through a fever by having all the blood drawn out of his body, when I know that three fall victims to a similar practice for every one that recovers? I pin my faith on no man's sleeve; but can truly subscribe myself

An Enquirer after Truth.

What sub-type of article is it?

Persuasive Informative Provocative

What themes does it cover?

Health Medicine Morality

What keywords are associated?

Bloodletting Medical Critique Excessive Bleeding Fever Treatment Cure Ratios Human Experiments Doctors Advantage

What entities or persons were involved?

An Enquirer After Truth Mr. Fenno

Letter to Editor Details

Author

An Enquirer After Truth

Recipient

Mr. Fenno

Main Argument

excessive bloodletting causes more deaths than cures, especially in fevers, and practitioners hide fatalities; they should publish cure-to-death ratios for fair comparison with other systems.

Notable Details

Compares Bloodletting Doctors To Highway Robbers Refers To Bleeding As 'Grand Panacea' 'Black List Of Victims' To Wanton Experiments Claims Three Deaths Per One Recovery

Are you sure?