Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for San Antonio Daily Light
Story January 24, 1906

San Antonio Daily Light

San Antonio, Bexar County, Texas

What is this article about?

The War Department received remarkable records of Captain Robert W. Rose's military trial in San Francisco for insubordination while a hospital patient, including his correspondence complaining of cruel and unnecessary confinement. General Funston believed the court's reprimand sentence did not fully match the findings.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

REMARKABLE RECORD IN CAPTAIN ROSE'S CASE

Special to The Light.

Washington, D. C., Jan. 24.—The war department has received the remarkable record in the case of Captain Robert W. Rose, of the Twenty-first infantry, who was tried in San Francisco before a military court for alleged insubordination and was sentenced to be reprimanded. The part of the record which is most interesting, is the copy of the correspondence in which Captain Rose indulged in with his senior officer. He was at the time of his alleged offence a patient under treatment at the army general hospital in San Francisco, and he addressed the military secretary of the department headquarters on one occasion, asking that if he were confronted with any charges, he be "proceeded against in a lawful and dignified manner." adding: "The treatment I am receiving here is not unusual and un-military, but it is cruel and unnecessary as I am not sick. My health is being confined by the confinement and torture. If I cannot secure relief from the military authorities I must, perforce, appeal to civil, as my health demands it." At another time he referred to the hospital and its surroundings as constituting "a novel situation, as it is my first term of confinement under the medical department." General Funston, who passed on the case thought that the court did not do full justice to the findings as expressed in the sentence.

What sub-type of article is it?

Biography Crime Story Historical Event

What themes does it cover?

Justice Crime Punishment Misfortune

What keywords are associated?

Military Trial Insubordination Hospital Confinement Captain Rose General Funston San Francisco War Department

What entities or persons were involved?

Captain Robert W. Rose General Funston

Where did it happen?

San Francisco

Story Details

Key Persons

Captain Robert W. Rose General Funston

Location

San Francisco

Event Date

Jan. 24.

Story Details

Captain Robert W. Rose, of the Twenty-first infantry, was tried in San Francisco for insubordination while a patient at the army general hospital, complaining in correspondence of cruel and unnecessary treatment and confinement affecting his health. He was sentenced to reprimand, but General Funston felt the court did not fully justice the findings.

Are you sure?