Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Potters Herald
Letter to Editor February 3, 1949

The Potters Herald

East Liverpool, Columbiana County, Ohio

What is this article about?

Ruth Taylor critiques loud, pressure-based arguments in the labor movement, advocating for clear, persuasive speech to convince workers, employers, and the public. She quotes Eric Peterson emphasizing skillful persuasion over volume in labor-management conciliation to foster understanding and peace.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

TOO LOUD TO HEAR
By RUTH TAYLOR

Don't you get annoyed with people who think that if they turn a radio up to the greatest volume, they will get clarity? I always want to call out "Turn it down! It's too loud to hear."

Haven't you known people who do just the same thing? The weaker their argument, the less they have to say, the louder they talk. They tune up rather than tune in. Instead of trying to get on the beam, they use pressure methods.

Yes, I know—I keep harping on this subject of speech—its content. its format, and so forth. BUT—can you tell me of any group to whom speech—or the clear presentation of facts—is more important than to the labor movement as a whole? You have to convince your fellow workers, your employers and the public of the justice of your case. You need good clear speech to put across your organization—so, by your leave, I shall keep right on harping on the subject.

In this connection, I am going to quote a labor man—Eric Peterson of the International Association of Machinists. It was at a meeting of the Speech Association of America in a program on "Speech in Conciliation" that he made what I—and the audience—thought a classic statement. Let me quote:

"The need for better lines of communication between labor and management, and between the conciliator and disputing parties, is a distinct challenge. For basically, the failure of these two groups to iron out their disputes without ill-will or violence is part and parcel of the broader problem of discord which plagues the world today in its quest for peace.

"Perhaps the starting point for the teachers is to pay a little less attention to Demosthenes, the ancient Greek, who became a great orator by practicing shouting until he could be heard above the roaring of the waves and a little more to developing men whose voices may not be loud, but whose skillful persuasion can be heard above the misunderstanding in men's hearts."

Mr. Peterson's last clause sums up the great communication problem not only of today but of all time. 'What is wanted is not loud talk—but talk that will be so bolstered by common understanding of common needs, that it will touch the hearts of men, destroying by its verity the misunderstandings that keep men apart.

There is a lesson in this for every labor leader—and for every one of us, as well. Restrain the tone of your voice, so that the tone of your heart may come through.

What sub-type of article is it?

Persuasive Reflective Informative

What themes does it cover?

Politics Social Issues

What keywords are associated?

Labor Movement Clear Speech Persuasive Communication Labor Management Conciliation Understanding

What entities or persons were involved?

Ruth Taylor

Letter to Editor Details

Author

Ruth Taylor

Main Argument

in the labor movement, effective advocacy requires clear, persuasive speech focused on content and understanding rather than loud, pressure-based arguments to convince stakeholders and resolve disputes peacefully.

Notable Details

Quotes Eric Peterson Of The International Association Of Machinists On Communication In Labor Conciliation References Speech Association Of America Meeting Contrasts Demosthenes' Shouting With Skillful Persuasion

Are you sure?