Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
June 13, 1861
The Daily Dispatch
Richmond, Virginia
What is this article about?
Editorial critiques hype around improved firearms, arguing victory depends on soldiers' courage rather than weapons, citing Philippi, Baltimore, Italian War, and Napoleon's battles. Emphasizes old arms suffice for determined fighters.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
The Talk about Improved Arms,
We hear a great deal in these days of "improved arms;" but while, no doubt, there has been some improvement, we question whether the exaggerations of their value have not done more harm than good. They have led men to rely on the weapon instead of themselves. The poor devils from Ohio and Pennsylvania, who, three to one, fought our troops at Philippi, were armed with Minnie muskets; yet most of their balls lodged in the trees. The improved arms of the Massachusetts Regiment, which was mobbed in passing through Baltimore, were no match for the improved men who, armed with brickbats and clubs, drove them howling through the streets. None of the battles of modern times have been as destructive of human life as those which occurred before the invention of gunpowder, when men fought with swords, spears, bows and arrows, &c., and trusted in themselves instead of their weapons. And notwithstanding all the improvements in cannon and muskets, the slaughter in the late Italian war was not to be compared to that in some of Napoleon's great battles, before any of these so-called improvements had been made.
The truth is, the old Virginia rifle, the old-fashioned musket, the double-barrel shot-gun, are all as good in the hands of a man who is bent on fight as any weapon that may be used. It is not the weapons, it is the men who use them, that decide a victory. Let a man's heart be influenced with vengeance and a love of country, and he will make the poorest weapon equal to the best "improvements." Anything that will send a ball—anything that will make a wound—is a dangerous weapon in the hands of a brave and determined man. On the other hand, the best weapons cannot supply the place of a courageous spirit and a good cause, and they who lean upon "improved" arms, and not upon valor and determination of soul, will find that they are leaning upon a broken reed.
We hear a great deal in these days of "improved arms;" but while, no doubt, there has been some improvement, we question whether the exaggerations of their value have not done more harm than good. They have led men to rely on the weapon instead of themselves. The poor devils from Ohio and Pennsylvania, who, three to one, fought our troops at Philippi, were armed with Minnie muskets; yet most of their balls lodged in the trees. The improved arms of the Massachusetts Regiment, which was mobbed in passing through Baltimore, were no match for the improved men who, armed with brickbats and clubs, drove them howling through the streets. None of the battles of modern times have been as destructive of human life as those which occurred before the invention of gunpowder, when men fought with swords, spears, bows and arrows, &c., and trusted in themselves instead of their weapons. And notwithstanding all the improvements in cannon and muskets, the slaughter in the late Italian war was not to be compared to that in some of Napoleon's great battles, before any of these so-called improvements had been made.
The truth is, the old Virginia rifle, the old-fashioned musket, the double-barrel shot-gun, are all as good in the hands of a man who is bent on fight as any weapon that may be used. It is not the weapons, it is the men who use them, that decide a victory. Let a man's heart be influenced with vengeance and a love of country, and he will make the poorest weapon equal to the best "improvements." Anything that will send a ball—anything that will make a wound—is a dangerous weapon in the hands of a brave and determined man. On the other hand, the best weapons cannot supply the place of a courageous spirit and a good cause, and they who lean upon "improved" arms, and not upon valor and determination of soul, will find that they are leaning upon a broken reed.
What sub-type of article is it?
Military Affairs
What keywords are associated?
Improved Arms
Military Valor
Weapon Effectiveness
Civil War Battles
Human Determination
What entities or persons were involved?
Ohio Troops
Pennsylvania Troops
Massachusetts Regiment
Napoleon
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Critique Of Overhyped Improved Arms
Stance / Tone
Skeptical Of Weapon Improvements Emphasizing Human Valor
Key Figures
Ohio Troops
Pennsylvania Troops
Massachusetts Regiment
Napoleon
Key Arguments
Exaggerations Of Improved Arms Lead Men To Rely On Weapons Instead Of Themselves
Historical Battles Before Gunpowder Were More Destructive
Slaughter In Italian War Less Than Napoleon's Battles
Old Weapons Like Virginia Rifle Effective In Determined Hands
Victory Decided By Men Not Weapons
Brave Man Makes Any Weapon Dangerous