Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Kalispell Bee
Editorial May 24, 1901

The Kalispell Bee

Kalispell, Flathead County, Montana

What is this article about?

Editorial denounces Game Warden Scott's appointment of his father as deputy in Montana as nepotism, a common US practice unlike in Canada or Britain. Cites examples of Secretary Hay appointing his son and Governor Toole his sister-in-law, arguing officials fail to hold relatives accountable.

Clipping

OCR Quality

100% Excellent

Full Text

Game Warden Scott's appointment of his father as one of his deputies is as disgraceful an act of nepotism as has occurred in Montana so far. However, the practice is common in the United States. In Canada or Great Britain the public official who would use his authority to provide soft places for his relatives would be hooted from office, but in this country it seems to be quite the thing. Secretary Hay appointed his son to a consulship and Governor Toole appointed his sister-in-law to an easy job in his office, so that Warden Scott is only following illustrious examples. The objection to the practice is plain. An official cannot or will not hold a relative to the same strict account as he would one who is not a relative, and the relative knowing this it is but natural that advantage should be taken of such a condition. However Warden Scott's appointment of his father is unique in a way. The practice of fathers appointing sons to soft jobs is common enough, but it is not often that the rule is reversed.

What sub-type of article is it?

Moral Or Religious

What keywords are associated?

Nepotism Public Appointments Government Ethics Accountability Montana

What entities or persons were involved?

Game Warden Scott Secretary Hay Governor Toole Montana Canada Great Britain

Editorial Details

Primary Topic

Nepotism In Public Appointments

Stance / Tone

Strongly Critical

Key Figures

Game Warden Scott Secretary Hay Governor Toole Montana Canada Great Britain

Key Arguments

Appointment Of Father By Son Is Disgraceful Nepotism Nepotism Common In Us But Condemned In Canada And Britain Officials Cannot Hold Relatives To Strict Account Relatives Take Advantage Of Leniency Examples Include Hay's Son As Consul And Toole's Sister In Law In Office Reversed Nepotism Of Son Appointing Father Is Unique

Are you sure?