Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Lynchburg Virginian
Story January 22, 1849

Lynchburg Virginian

Lynchburg, Virginia

What is this article about?

A New York Evening Post article claims Gen. Wool deserves credit for the Battle of Buena Vista victory, prompting calls for him to respond. Critics argue this undermines Gen. Taylor's leadership, who advised against retreat and won the battle on February 23. The attempt is seen as vain and malicious.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

A leading article in the New York Evening Post, written with an attention to dates which implies that it was prompted by Gen. Wool himself, boldly claims for that officer the credit of the battle of Buena Vista. The Courier and Enquirer calls upon Gen. Wool to avow, or disavow, the pretensions thus set up for him. So far he has not done either and we may expect disclosures which will not tend to add to the fame of the second in command on that day. Gen. Taylor has never manifested a nervous, fidgetty uneasiness lest his countrymen should not do him full justice. He has, at all times, been ready to do ample justice to the merits of his subordinates.—But he is not the man to sit calmly by when an attempt, originating in personal vanity or party intolerance, is made to bestow upon another laurels which are justly his own.

Gen. Wool is a good disciplinarian, and a brave man, doubtless, though of not much intellectual vigor.—We regret to see him lending himself to such a scheme. The attempt to injure the reputation of Old Rough and Ready will recoil upon its authors.

The Washington correspondent of the North American says:

"When the truth of history shall have been recorded, the singular fact may be disclosed, that he for whom indiscreet friends have claimed a distinction of the highest and most commanding prominence, was one of those who advised a retreat, when the bloody scene of the 23d of February had closed and the fate of the field had been decided. If there is not testimony in existence under Gen. Wool's own hand, to the effect that no other man than General Taylor could have won that great battle, my information is strangely at fault. But what needs there of witnesses to prove what the monuments of the dead and the lips of living actors have vouched in language that no historian can improve? The audacity of this pretension is only equalled by its absurdity; but the temerity with which it has been ventured, exhibits a purpose which is doubly barbed with malice and ambition."

What sub-type of article is it?

Historical Event Military Action

What themes does it cover?

Justice Deception Triumph

What keywords are associated?

Buena Vista Battle Gen Wool Credit Claim Gen Taylor Leadership Military Controversy Historical Dispute

What entities or persons were involved?

Gen. Wool Gen. Taylor Old Rough And Ready

Where did it happen?

Buena Vista

Story Details

Key Persons

Gen. Wool Gen. Taylor Old Rough And Ready

Location

Buena Vista

Event Date

23d Of February

Story Details

New York Evening Post claims Gen. Wool credit for Buena Vista battle victory, prompted by him; Courier and Enquirer demands response. Critics defend Gen. Taylor's leadership, noting Wool advised retreat after battle decided; Taylor's testimony praises his own indispensable role. Scheme seen as vain, malicious attempt to steal Taylor's laurels.

Are you sure?