Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Republican Journal
Story January 13, 1870

The Republican Journal

Belfast, Waldo County, Maine

What is this article about?

An editorial harshly criticizes Edwin M. Stanton for sabotaging General McClellan's Peninsula Campaign in 1862, blaming him for prolonging the Civil War and comparing him to tyrants like Robespierre. It opposes his potential Supreme Court appointment, crediting divine intervention for his death.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

EDWIN M. STANTON AGAIN.

The Prog Age don't like our remarks about Stanton, and complains that we have not credited him with ability. Doubtless he had ability. So has the devil. A man can't make such a hell upon earth as Edwin M. Stanton did, without the possession of some force of character.

We care not what is said by papers like the Age. But if any of our friends think we have said too much, we ask them to carry their recollections back to the time when Gen. McClellan had invested Richmond, and with his plans perfected was pushing rapidly into victory. It was the malignant interference of Stanton that caused the withdrawal of troops on which the General relied, and compelled the retreat to Harrison's Landing. Stanton's interference and Lee's generalship worked together to crush the army, that was saved only by the genius of its commander.

It was then that McClellan addressed to Stanton these words, wrung from his agonized heart-

"I know that a few thousand more men would have changed this battle from a defeat to a victory. As it is the government must not and cannot hold me responsible for the result. I feel too earnestly to-night. I have seen too many dead and wounded comrades to feel otherwise than that the government has not sustained this army. If you do not do so the game is lost. If I save this army now, I tell you plainly that I owe no thanks to you, or to any other person in Washington. You have done your best to sacrifice this army."

For the dead men who strewed that field, and for the prolonging of that war for years, Stanton was directly responsible. Does anybody suppose we are going to worship the memory of such a man?

Stanton was the incarnation of all the hideousness of war and desolation. The troublous times of a revolution generally throw one such man to the surface. There was Jeffries in England, Robespierre in France, Haynau in Austria, Stanton in America. The radical party never put on an aspect so threatening and dangerous to the liberties of the country as when it sought to place that man on the bench of the Supreme Court, and at the same time to pass a law restraining the Court from its supervision of a certain class of laws. His overbearing will, his bad heart, his terrible audacity would have made everything bend before him, if it were possible. If those linked with him had willed a despotism, what better instrument, and what better place, than Edwin M. Stanton as Judge of the Supreme Court. If ever an overruling Providence directly interfered for the good of a people, it was when He laid the hand of death on that reckless, unscrupulous, man.

What sub-type of article is it?

Historical Event Biography Tragedy

What themes does it cover?

Betrayal Misfortune Justice

What keywords are associated?

Edwin Stanton Mcclellan Campaign Peninsula Retreat Civil War Prolongation Supreme Court Nomination Political Tyranny

What entities or persons were involved?

Edwin M. Stanton Gen. Mcclellan Lee Jeffries Robespierre Haynau

Where did it happen?

Richmond, Harrison's Landing

Story Details

Key Persons

Edwin M. Stanton Gen. Mcclellan Lee Jeffries Robespierre Haynau

Location

Richmond, Harrison's Landing

Event Date

The Time When Gen. Mcclellan Had Invested Richmond

Story Details

Critique of Stanton's interference in McClellan's campaign leading to retreat and prolonged war, quoting McClellan's letter blaming the government, comparing Stanton to tyrants, and opposing his Supreme Court nomination as a threat to liberties, with his death seen as providential.

Are you sure?