Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for The Daily Advertiser
Letter to Editor September 20, 1788

The Daily Advertiser

New York, New York County, New York

What is this article about?

A letter to Mr. Childs criticizes a committee's attempt to persuade Mr. Maxwell to step aside for Col. Lewis as North Ward Alderman, arguing it undermines the unity from the Sardini's meeting on the 15th and the published list signed by Nicholas Low, potentially harming city reform efforts.

Clipping

OCR Quality

98% Excellent

Full Text

Mr. CHILDS,

In looking over your paper of this day, I was a good deal surprised to see a paragraph, intimating that a committee of gentlemen had waited on Mr. Maxwell, to inform him that it would be agreeable to many gentlemen of the North Ward, that Col. Lewis, should be elected Alderman of it. It appears, that the design of the embassy was to obtain from Mr. Maxwell, a relinquishment of his pretensions to the votes of the Electors of the North-Ward: The result was exactly such as must have been expected. Mr. Maxwell assured the gentlemen, that he not only willingly resigned in favor of Mr. Lewis, but that he would give him his vote and interest. I can easily believe that Mr. Maxwell would not be anxious to be placed in a situation, which, tho' honorable, must be very troublesome, where no profit is intended to be made by it. I believe also, that so far from being desirous of the appointment, he rather submits in this instance to the judgment and wishes of his fellow-citizens, than solicits their support. I consider the assurances given by Mr. Maxwell to the committee who waited on him, to have been in some measure extorted, since no gentleman, circumstanced as he then was, could argue on the propriety of the change which they proposed. Every gentleman who met at Sardini's on the 15th, pledged himself expressly to support the list, as it was published with the signature of Nicholas Low. I apprehend therefore, none who were present at that meeting can countenance any change. If it be practicable to change the Aldermen, it must be effected, not by the undisputed necessity of the measure, nor by lazy wishes—but by the active and united exertions of all those freemen and freeholders, who view the reputation of the city, as affected by the choice of its Magistracy.—If there be a single Alderman in the city, who is deemed unworthy of that station, it matters not in what ward he is placed, whether in the North or in the South, he equally discredits the citizens at large, and dishonors the appointment—If the list published by the authority of the meeting on the fifteenth instant, be altered, it will have a direct tendency to continue the evil which we seem disposed to remedy; it will render some discontented and others indifferent; it will divide that interest which can alone introduce reform; I mean the union of all those citizens who think it of importance to see the bench supported by the most respectable character, amongst us. Upon the whole, unless Mr. Maxwell formally resigns (which by the bye I hope he will not) it would be not less improper than indelicate to attempt an alteration.

What sub-type of article is it?

Persuasive Political

What themes does it cover?

Politics

What keywords are associated?

North Ward Alderman Election Mr Maxwell Col Lewis Political Unity City Reform Sardini Meeting

What entities or persons were involved?

Mr. Childs

Letter to Editor Details

Recipient

Mr. Childs

Main Argument

opposes the committee's effort to replace mr. maxwell with col. lewis as north ward alderman, viewing maxwell's assurances as extorted and arguing that altering the agreed list from the sardini's meeting would divide citizens and undermine reform for respectable city magistracy.

Notable Details

Meeting At Sardini's On The 15th List Published With Signature Of Nicholas Low Committee Waited On Mr. Maxwell North Ward Election

Are you sure?