Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!

Sign up free
Page thumbnail for Cincinnati Daily Press
Story March 31, 1860

Cincinnati Daily Press

Cincinnati, Hamilton County, Ohio

What is this article about?

Editorial critiques the Gazette's endorsement of Mr. Bates as Republican, highlighting contradictions in slavery policy: Gazette opposes new slave states, while Bates supports states' self-determination and congressional power to permit slavery in territories.

Clipping

OCR Quality

95% Excellent

Full Text

The Republican Standard.

The Gazette winds up its effort at defining Republican principles by the more convenient generalization that Mr. Bates comes fully up to its standard of Republicanism. But the slight inquiry which we instituted brought the Gazette to a declaration against the admission of another slave State out of our own territory, and against the acquisition of any foreign slave States which were to have the control of this domestic relation. This, certainly, is not Mr. Bates's doctrine. The article in the St. Louis Democrat, which is generally accepted as official, especially repudiated the doctrine of "No more slave States," and, in his letter, he declares, that when a State is admitted, she should be "the sole judge of her own Constitution." Also, Mr. Bates says, in regard to the territories, that "The National Government has the power to permit or forbid slavery within them." What is "the power to permit?" And what difference is there between the power to permit and the power to protect slavery in the territories? Does not one necessarily follow the other? Is this anything but the doctrine of congressional protection of slavery in the territories? And yet the Gazette says Mr. Bates comes fully up to its standard of Republicanism.

Is it not more than a little doubtful whether there is any standard of Republican doctrine, and does it not grow mythical when it is sought to be defined.

What sub-type of article is it?

Historical Event

What themes does it cover?

Deception Justice Moral Virtue

What keywords are associated?

Republican Principles Slavery Policy Mr Bates Slave States Territories Congressional Power

What entities or persons were involved?

Mr. Bates Gazette St. Louis Democrat

Where did it happen?

St. Louis

Story Details

Key Persons

Mr. Bates Gazette St. Louis Democrat

Location

St. Louis

Story Details

Critique of Gazette's claim that Mr. Bates meets Republican standards on slavery, pointing out inconsistencies between Gazette's anti-expansion stance and Bates's support for state self-determination and congressional permission of slavery in territories, questioning the existence of a clear Republican doctrine.

Are you sure?