Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
November 8, 1831
Rhode Island American And Gazette
Providence, Providence County, Rhode Island
What is this article about?
This editorial from the New-York Daily Advertiser defends the militia's ridicule of burdensome and oppressive military parade laws, arguing it is harmless, justified by failed legislative reforms, and unlikely to extend to other laws. It criticizes the system's lack of benefits and influence of officers.
OCR Quality
95%
Excellent
Full Text
From the New-York Daily Advertiser.
Complaints have in some instances been made against the late attempts among the militia, to ridicule the military parades in the manner required by the existing laws. It is said, that although the system is burdensome, useless, and oppressive, it is still dangerous to bring the laws into contempt, because, if it can be done in this case, it may be done in others, and eventually be the means of serious evils to the community.
We do not view the matter in this formidable light. The complaints on the part of the militia have long existed, and have become very extensive. The burden falls heavily upon numerous class of people who are the least able to bear it; and as they are not able to discern any practical advantages, either to the public or themselves, from the operation of the system, it is not strange that they should be discontented under it.
Applications have been repeatedly made to the Legislature for an alteration in the laws, and it appeared at the last session that they were in a fair way of succeeding; but they eventually failed, and the militia believe—on what evidence we do not know—that they are, from session to session, defeated by the influence and exertions of militia officers.
Under this impression, and in this state of things, they have resorted to a principle which is often found efficacious in human affairs, viz. ridicule. They do not refuse to do every thing that the laws require, They have all the equipments which are ordered. But they go farther, and do more than the laws require—they present themselves in a ludicrous light to the public, in order to get rid of a system which seems to have but few advocates, except among those whose importance among their fellow-citizens depends, in some measure, upon its continuance.
We are not able to perceive that any mischief is likely to arise from the adoption of this course by the militia. If the system should be altered and improved—which may easily be done—it will be so much the better. If it should not be altered, the system—with all its burdens and oppression—will remain as it now is.
But it is said other laws may be ridiculed. Of this we have doubts. We know of very few laws of importance that are liable to be attacked in this way. No man who is the subject of laws of a criminal or penal nature, can easily turn them into ridicule. A man who is in a state prison, or penitentiary, or is confined under sentence for some penal offence, has very few materials in his possession, growing out of his circumstances, which will have any tendency to raise a laugh on his side. And there is as little danger in the general laws of the land respecting property, character, or personal security, that will lead to such a result.
The truth is, the militia system is extremely burdensome and odious, and if it cannot be got rid of in any other mode, it is, in our judgment, a fair subject of ridicule.
Complaints have in some instances been made against the late attempts among the militia, to ridicule the military parades in the manner required by the existing laws. It is said, that although the system is burdensome, useless, and oppressive, it is still dangerous to bring the laws into contempt, because, if it can be done in this case, it may be done in others, and eventually be the means of serious evils to the community.
We do not view the matter in this formidable light. The complaints on the part of the militia have long existed, and have become very extensive. The burden falls heavily upon numerous class of people who are the least able to bear it; and as they are not able to discern any practical advantages, either to the public or themselves, from the operation of the system, it is not strange that they should be discontented under it.
Applications have been repeatedly made to the Legislature for an alteration in the laws, and it appeared at the last session that they were in a fair way of succeeding; but they eventually failed, and the militia believe—on what evidence we do not know—that they are, from session to session, defeated by the influence and exertions of militia officers.
Under this impression, and in this state of things, they have resorted to a principle which is often found efficacious in human affairs, viz. ridicule. They do not refuse to do every thing that the laws require, They have all the equipments which are ordered. But they go farther, and do more than the laws require—they present themselves in a ludicrous light to the public, in order to get rid of a system which seems to have but few advocates, except among those whose importance among their fellow-citizens depends, in some measure, upon its continuance.
We are not able to perceive that any mischief is likely to arise from the adoption of this course by the militia. If the system should be altered and improved—which may easily be done—it will be so much the better. If it should not be altered, the system—with all its burdens and oppression—will remain as it now is.
But it is said other laws may be ridiculed. Of this we have doubts. We know of very few laws of importance that are liable to be attacked in this way. No man who is the subject of laws of a criminal or penal nature, can easily turn them into ridicule. A man who is in a state prison, or penitentiary, or is confined under sentence for some penal offence, has very few materials in his possession, growing out of his circumstances, which will have any tendency to raise a laugh on his side. And there is as little danger in the general laws of the land respecting property, character, or personal security, that will lead to such a result.
The truth is, the militia system is extremely burdensome and odious, and if it cannot be got rid of in any other mode, it is, in our judgment, a fair subject of ridicule.
What sub-type of article is it?
Military Affairs
Legal Reform
What keywords are associated?
Militia System
Military Parades
Ridicule Protest
Legislative Reform
Burdensome Laws
Militia Officers
What entities or persons were involved?
Militia
Legislature
Militia Officers
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Defense Of Militia Ridicule Against Burdensome Laws
Stance / Tone
Supportive Of Ridicule As Harmless Protest
Key Figures
Militia
Legislature
Militia Officers
Key Arguments
Militia Complaints Are Longstanding And Widespread Due To The System's Burdens
Legislative Reform Efforts Have Failed, Possibly Due To Officers' Influence
Ridicule Complies With Laws But Highlights Their Absurdity To Push For Change
No Serious Harm From This Approach; It May Lead To Improvement
Other Important Laws Are Not Easily Ridiculed