Alexandria Gazette

The discussion of the question, "Ought American Slavery to be perpetuated," was commenced in Philadelphia on the evening of the 7th inst. between Parson Brownlow, of Tennessee, and the Rev. A. Pryne, of New York, at the National Guards Hall, Race street.

One hundred persons, principally males, were present. In consequence of Parson Brownlow suffering from an affection of the throat, he was unable to participate in person, and his opening was read by Mr. Wm. F. Small.

In the opening, the position was assumed that slavery has existed in all ages and in all countries--that it was recognized of God in the commandment, "Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's wife, nor his man-servant nor his maid-servant," &c., the word servant in the Hebrew, signifying slave.

After numerous references to bible history, in support of the position that slavery is of divine origin, the subject of abolitionism was touched upon; also the slave trade, about which much was said, not however, approvingly.

The opening assumed, and attempted to show, by history, that the slave trade was mainly carried on by northern men, the vessels being fitted out in eastern ports.

The reading of the opening occupied more than an hour. Mr. Pryne followed in answer, and spoke up to the adjournment. He, of course, took a free soil view of the subject.

Both speakers were applauded by their respective friends. The question to be discussed was not touched upon by Mr. Brownlow, it being reserved for a future evening.