Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up free
Editorial
September 23, 1854
Thibodaux Minerva
Thibodaux, Lafourche County, Louisiana
What is this article about?
Editorial criticizes President Pierce for inconsistency on federal appropriations for Western rivers and harbors, citing Judge Wording's account of Pierce's 1852 statements supporting such improvements, contrasting with current actions.
OCR Quality
98%
Excellent
Full Text
The Western journals are convicting President Pierce of double-dealing and failing to keep his word in the matter of River and Harbor Improvements. On this head Judge Wording, of Racine, Wis., makes the following asseverations:
"I would state that in the month of October, 1852, I was in the office of Gen. Pierce, in Concord, New Hampshire, and had at that time a conversation with him in relation to appropriations by the General Government for the improvement of Western Rivers and Harbors. Taking a bound volume of printed speeches and letters in his hand, he turned to the letter of Silas Wright to the Chicago Convention, and observed that the sentiments of that letter were his own; that he was not in favor of appropriations by the General Government for the purpose of creating commerce in places where it did not exist, but wherever it did exist, it ought to be protected and encouraged, and that he had no more doubt of the constitutionality and expediency of appropriations by the General Government for the improvement of Western Harbors and Rivers than he had of the constitutionality and expediency of appropriations by the General Government for the construction of light-houses and other similar objects on the Atlantic coast: and he added, I understand the letter of Silas Wright to the Chicago Convention to be satisfactory to all Western men.' These are his statements as then made, and to show that I am not mistaken, I copy this statement of his from a memorandum then made, at Gen. Pierce's own suggestion."
"I would state that in the month of October, 1852, I was in the office of Gen. Pierce, in Concord, New Hampshire, and had at that time a conversation with him in relation to appropriations by the General Government for the improvement of Western Rivers and Harbors. Taking a bound volume of printed speeches and letters in his hand, he turned to the letter of Silas Wright to the Chicago Convention, and observed that the sentiments of that letter were his own; that he was not in favor of appropriations by the General Government for the purpose of creating commerce in places where it did not exist, but wherever it did exist, it ought to be protected and encouraged, and that he had no more doubt of the constitutionality and expediency of appropriations by the General Government for the improvement of Western Harbors and Rivers than he had of the constitutionality and expediency of appropriations by the General Government for the construction of light-houses and other similar objects on the Atlantic coast: and he added, I understand the letter of Silas Wright to the Chicago Convention to be satisfactory to all Western men.' These are his statements as then made, and to show that I am not mistaken, I copy this statement of his from a memorandum then made, at Gen. Pierce's own suggestion."
What sub-type of article is it?
Infrastructure
Economic Policy
Partisan Politics
What keywords are associated?
River Improvements
Harbor Appropriations
Pierce Inconsistency
Western Commerce
Federal Funding
What entities or persons were involved?
President Pierce
Judge Wording
Silas Wright
Western Journals
Editorial Details
Primary Topic
Criticism Of Pierce's Inconsistency On River And Harbor Appropriations
Stance / Tone
Accusatory Of Double Dealing
Key Figures
President Pierce
Judge Wording
Silas Wright
Western Journals
Key Arguments
Pierce Expressed Support For Federal Appropriations To Protect Existing Western Commerce In 1852
Pierce Equated Western Improvements To Atlantic Lighthouses In Constitutionality And Expediency
Pierce Endorsed Silas Wright's Letter As Satisfactory To Western Men
Current Actions Contradict These Earlier Statements