Thank you for visiting SNEWPapers!
Sign up freeColumbus Democrat
Columbus, Lowndes County, Mississippi
What is this article about?
Partisan newspaper exchange where the Democrat defends its measured praise of Senator James F. Trotter's honorable Senate service against the Argus's accusation of 'damning with faint praise' and misrepresentation, contrasting it with Whig flattery of orators like Prentiss.
OCR Quality
Full Text
"We do not mean by this that he [Judge Trotter] has displayed extraordinary talents or that he has taken a very prominent part in the important debates of the Senate."-Argus.
The Arch Fiend himself might well envy "the tact and talent" which the Argus displays for misrepresentation and falsehood. The article in the Democrat from which the above garbled extract is taken, is highly laudatory of Judge Trotter-it does not indeed exhibit the fulsome panegyric which the Whig press pour out in such disgusting strains upon their federal orator, Mr. Prentiss, but it tells the truth, which is all that Judge Trotter ever wishes to be said of him. The Judge had been but a short time in the Senate, and was one of its youngest members, of course it could hardly be expected that he would make any extraordinary display, or take a very prominent part in the debates. He has modesty and good sense; characteristics rarely to be found in the federal ranks. How far we have been guilty of "damning him with faint praise," will be seen from the following extracts from the article in the Democrat which called forth the above squib from the Argus man'
"There is not one of our public men who has gained so enviable a distinction in so short a period of public service, as our Senator, the Hon. Jas. F. Trotter. We do not mean by this that he has displayed extraordinary talents, or that he has taken a very prominent part in the important debates of the Senate." [Observe, we did not mean by this that the Judge had not the talents to take such prominent part ] "He has won his way to distinction and popularity in that body by other means than these-means more honorable to him as a man, and legislator, and more conducive to the interests of his constituents. Judge Trotter does not think that he was sent to Congress merely to make a display, and acquire notoriety by much speaking. His mission, he thinks is for higher and nobler purposes."
"He has shown himself an able and eloquent advocate for the interests of his constituents whenever occasion required it. Witness his excellent speech, delivered in the Senate, 3d of July, on the bill to authorise the State of Mississippi to invest the two per cent fund."
Of course this is "faint praise," in the estimation of the Federalists, who have been in the habit of extolling such trashy and ephemeral orators as Prentiss of Mississippi, and Menifee of Kentucky, as "above all Greek, above all Roman fame." For ourselves we shall always be content to tell the simple truth, leaving it to the more courtly Editors of the Federal press to fawn, and flatter, and lie.
What sub-type of article is it?
What themes does it cover?
What keywords are associated?
What entities or persons were involved?
Where did it happen?
Story Details
Key Persons
Location
United States Senate, Mississippi
Event Date
July 28th; July 3rd
Story Details
The Democrat publishes a laudatory article on Senator James F. Trotter's honorable and effective service in the Senate, emphasizing his modesty and advocacy for constituents over showy speeches. The Argus misrepresents an excerpt as 'faint praise,' prompting this defense that accuses the Argus of falsehood and contrasts truthful praise with Whig exaggeration of orators like Prentiss and Menifee.